Maryland case law › A.H. Kuhlemann v. Corkran, Hill Baltimore Butterine

A.H. Kuhlemann v. Corkran, Hill Baltimore Butterine

136 Md. 539 (1920) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: AffirmedPattison✓ Good law
SummaryThis case is a companion to Corkran, Hill & Co. v. The A. H. Kuhlemann Co. (No. 22), decided at the same term. In the earlier case, The A. H. Kuhlemann Co. sought to restrain Corkran, Hill & Co. from using the trade-mark "Orange Brand" on cartons in the purchase, manufacture, or sale of oleomargarine. The lower court dismissed that bill, but this Court reversed and remanded with directions to pass an injunction as prayed. In the present case, the appellant, A. H. Kuhlemann, filed a bill asking for an injunction restraining the appellee, Corkran, Hill & Co., from using the same trade-mark "Orange Brand" upon its cartons, or otherwise, in the purchase, manufacture, or sale of oleomargarine, and for other relief not stated. The lower court dismissed this bill as well. On appeal, the Court of Appeals affirmed the order denying the injunction, expressly resting its decision on the reasons sta
Questions presented
  • Whether the appellant was entitled to an injunction restraining the appellee from using the trade-mark "Orange Brand" upon its cartons, or otherwise, in the purchase, manufacture or sale of oleomargarine.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Pattison, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. The bill in. this ease was filed by the appellant asking for an injunction, restraining the appellee from using the trader mark “Orange Brand” upon its cartons, or otherwise, in the purchase, manufacture or sale of oleomargarine, and for other relief which we deem unnecessary here to state. This, bill was filed after the Court had dismissed thei bill in Oorkran, Hill & Co. vs,. The A. H. Kuhlemann Co. (No,. 22), decided at this term, in which The A. H. Kuhlemann Co. asked that Corkran, Hill & Co. be restrained in the use of said trade-mark for like purposes.

The Court below dismissed the bill in that case, but upon an appeal to this Court, the order dismissing the bill was reversed and the case remanded that an injunction be passed as prayed. Eor the reasons stated by this Court in its opinion in that case (Oorkran, Hill & Co. vsi The A. H. Kuhlemann Co.) for reversing the decree of the lower Court, the order of the Court below in denying the injunction in this, case will be affirmed. Decree affirmed, with costs to the appellee.