Maryland case law › Adair v. State

Adair v. State

231 Md. 255 (1963) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Affirmed✓ Good law
SummaryIn a per curiam opinion, the Court of Appeals affirmed the appellant's convictions, entered by a jury, of assault with intent to rape Florence Scheidt and of assault upon Mildred Harmon. The appellant was sentenced to life imprisonment on the first charge and twenty years on the second, to run consecutively. The Court rejected several contentions. First, the trial judge correctly denied the appellant's prayers relating to abandonment of purpose because the factual situation did not justify granting them; the appellant's own testimony disclosed an assault with intent to rape. Second, the twenty-year sentence for assault did not constitute cruel and unusual punishment under Articles 16 and 25 of the Maryland Declaration of Rights. Third, the absence of members of the Negro race from the jury, standing alone, did not establish the denial of a fair and impartial trial. Fourth, the questions
Questions presented
  • Whether the trial judge erred in denying appellant's prayers relating to abandonment of purpose.
  • Whether the sentence of twenty years' confinement for assault constituted cruel and unusual punishment contrary to Articles 16 and 25 of the Maryland Declaration of Rights.
  • Whether the fact that no members of the Negro race were upon the jury established the denial of a fair and impartial trial.
  • Whether the questions relating to the admissibility of evidence were properly before the Court.
  • Whether the bare allegations that appellant was 'a victim of circumstances' and that the State withheld evidence required answers.
  • Whether the claim that the pretrial psychiatric examination was only of about fifteen minutes duration and consequently incomplete was properly before the Court.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Per Curiam. Appellant was convicted by a jury of assault with intent to rape Florence Scheidt, and, under another indictment, of assault upon Mildred Harmon. He was sentenced to life imprisonment in the first case, and to twenty years’ confinement in the second, the sentences to run consecutively. The trial judge was correct in denying appellant’s prayers relating to abandonment of purpose.

The factual situation did not justify their being granted. Appellant’s own testimony disclosed an assault with intent to rape. Cf. Duffin v. State, 229 Md. 434 , 184 A. 2d 624 .

The sentence of twenty years’ confinement for assault did not constitute “cruel and unusual punishment” contrary to Articles 16 and 25 of the Maryland Declaration of Rights. Cf. Heath v. State, 198 Md. 455 , 85 A. 2d 43 ; Duff v. State, 229 Md. 126 , 182 A. 2d 349 . The fact that no members of the Negro race were upon the jury, alone, does not establish the denial of a fair and impartial trial.

Giles v. State, 229 Md. 370 , 183 A. 2d 359 . The fourth and fifth questions, relating to the admissibility of evidence are not before us, no objection having been made below. Maryland Rule 522 d 2. The bare allegations that appellant was “a victim of circumstances,” and “he now alleges that the State withheld evidence” do not require answers.

The claim, not argued in his brief (Cf. Maryland Rule 831 d 4), that “the pretrial psychiatric examination * * * [of appellant at the request of his 257 counsel] was only of about fifteen minutes duration and consequently incomplete” was not raised below, hence it is not properly before us. Maryland Rules 885 and 772. Judgments affirmed.