Maryland case law › Arch v. Arch

Arch v. Arch

11 Md. App. 395 (1971) · Court of Special Appeals of Maryland
Court of Special Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Affirmed✓ Good law
SummaryIn this per curiam opinion, the Court of Special Appeals of Maryland declined the appellant wife's invitation to overrule a long line of Maryland cases, culminating in Stokes v. Association of Independent Taxi Operators, Inc., 248 Md. 690, 237 A.2d 762 (1968), which hold that a wife cannot recover at law from her husband for a negligent tort. The court noted that no arguments were presented that had not already been considered and rejected by the Court of Appeals of Maryland, citing Hudson v. Hudson, 226 Md. 521, 174 A.2d 339; Ennis v. Donovan, 222 Md. 536, 161 A.2d 698; and Fernandez v. Fernandez, 214 Md. 519, 135 A.2d 886. The court observed that Maryland follows the majority of states, 43 A.L.R.2d 632, and that the legislature had not altered the long-established rule. The appellant argued that the instant case should be distinguished because the parties were separated and had execute
Questions presented
  • Should the Court overrule the long line of Maryland cases holding that a wife cannot recover at law from her husband for a negligent tort?
  • Should the instant case be distinguished from prior cases because the parties were separated and had executed a separation agreement?
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Per Curiam. The appellant argues we should overrule a long line of Maryland cases ending with Stokes v. Association of Independent Taxi Operators, Inc., 248 Md. 690 , 237 A. 2d 762 (1968) holding a wife cannot recover at law from her husband for a negligent tort. We decline to do so. No arguments are presented which have not been previously considered and rejected by the Court of Appeals of Maryland.

See Hudson v. Hudson, 226 Md. 521 , 174 A. 2d 339 , Ennis v. Donovan, 222 Md. 536 , 161 A. 2d 698 , Fernan 396 dez v. Fernandez, 214 Md. 519 , 135 A. 2d 886 and cases cited therein. We note that Maryland follows the majority of states. 43 A.L.R.2d 632 . We also note the absence of legislation altering this long established rule. See Latz v. Latz, 10 Md. App. 720 , 272 A. 2d 434 as to suits between parents and unemancipated children.

We will, however, briefly discuss one point. The appellant strenuously argues we should distinguish the instant case from prior cases because the parties were separated and had executed a separation agreement. The cases of Gregg v. Gregg, 199 Md. 662 , 87 A. 2d 581 and Fernandez v. Fernandez, supra indicate that separation of the parties does not vary the rule. The appellee has filed a motion to strike a purported copy of the separation agreement from the appellant’s brief.

The agreement was not a part of the record and we have given it no consideration; we would grant the motion if there were any practical reason to do so, but since appellant will, under our mandate, be required to pay all of the costs, there is no practical reason to grant the motion. Judgment affirmed. Appellant to pay the costs.