Maryland case law › Attorney Grievance Commission v. Geesing

Attorney Grievance Commission v. Geesing

436 Md. 56 (2013) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: OtherAdkins, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis opinion is a concurrence and dissent by Judge Adkins in Attorney Grievance Commission v. Geesing, 436 Md. 56 (2013). Judge Adkins concurred with the majority's opinion except for its rejection of the distinction Respondent Geesing drew between his conduct and that of Mr. Dore in Attorney Grievance Comm'n of Maryland v. Dore, 433 Md. 685, 73 A.3d 161 (2013). The distinction was that Geesing testified, and the hearing judge found, that he reviewed each affidavit before his staff person signed his name, whereas in Dore there was no such testimony. Although both attorneys violated the same Rules of Professional Conduct, Judge Adkins viewed Geesing's conduct as less culpable. When a lawyer reviews each affidavit and approves its specific content, the lawyer knows the substance, including exact detail, of what will be presented to the court as his oath. This differs qualitatively from Dor
Questions presented
  • Whether the distinction drawn by Respondent Geesing—that he reviewed each affidavit before his staff person signed his name, unlike Mr. Dore—should be rejected in determining the appropriate sanction.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

ADKINS, J., concurring and dissenting. I concur with the majority opinion except with respect to its rejection of the distinction drawn by Respondent that, in contrast to Mr. Dore, he testified, and the hearing judge found, that he reviewed each affidavit before his staff person signed his name. In Attorney Grievance Comm’n of Maryland v. Dore, there was no such testimony. 433 Md. 685 , 73 A.3d 161 (2013). Although both attorneys violated the same Rules of Professional Conduct, in my view, Geesing’s conduct was less culpable.

When a lawyer reviews each affidavit and approves its specific content, the lawyer knows the substance, including exact detail, of what will be presented to the court as his oath. This differs qualitatively, in my view, from Dore’s more general delegation to non-lawyer office staff to sign his name on affidavits to be filed in court. Nevertheless, given the high volume of these flawed mortgage affidavits, and the negative impact on the legal profession caused by public perception of the Bar as having a cavalier attitude towards the very serious responsibility of filing affidavits in foreclosure actions, I would suspend Geesing for 60 days.