Maryland case law › Austin v. Austin

Austin v. Austin

234 Md. 393 (1964) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Affirmed✓ Good law
SummaryThe appellee-husband obtained an absolute divorce from the appellant-wife on the ground of the wife's adultery, and the wife's cross-complaint seeking a divorce on the ground of abandonment was dismissed. Within the time allowed by Maryland Rule 690, the wife, through new counsel, filed a petition for rehearing alleging that she had 'available new, other and additional evidence' that, had it been presented at trial, 'would have had an important and material effect' on the decree, and asserting that the husband 'did on numerous occasions commit adultery with divers women.' The petition was verified by the wife alone. The husband answered, and both counsel were heard. The chancellor asked appellant's counsel to state why the additional evidence could not have been presented at trial and what the new evidence was; neither question was answered directly or specifically. The chancellor denied
Questions presented
  • Whether the appellant's petition for rehearing complied with Maryland Rule 690, which requires the petition to contain the special matter on which the hearing is applied for and, if not apparent on the record, to have the facts verified by the party or some other person.
  • Whether the chancellor abused his discretion in denying the petition for rehearing.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

PER Curiam. On May 13, 1963, Judge Jones granted the appellee an absolute divorce on the ground of appellant’s having committed adultery, and dismissed appellant’s complaint, which had prayed a divorce on the ground of abandonment. Within the time prescribed by Maryland Rule 690, appellant sought a rehearing, after obtaining new counsel. Her petition alleged that she had “available new, other and 394 additional evidence that, had it been presented in open court at the time of trial would have had an important and material effect” on the court’s decree; “that by way of new, other and additional evidence your petitioner says that the [appellee] did on numerous occasions commit adultery with divers women.” The petition was verified by appellant alone.

The petition was answered, and counsel for both parties were heard by the court. Counsel for appellant was asked to state the reasons why the additional evidence could not have been presented at the trial, and “what is the new, other and additional evidence.” Neither question was answered directly or specifically. The Chancellor denied the petition. Rule 690 provides that the petition “shall contain the special matter on which such hearing is applied for * * * and the facts therein stated, if not apparent on the record, shall be verified by the party, or some other person.” The allegations in appellant’s petition were, we think, too general in nature to comply with this Rule.

The name of no witness was given, nor were there allegations as to what the witnesses would testify to. The allegations were no more than conclusions of the appellant. It is well-established law that the granting or refusal of a rehearing is in the discretion of the trial court, and, in order that an appeal from its action be successful, there must be a showing of injustice to the petitioner or an abuse of discretion by the court, Holcomb v. Fender, 203 Md. 480 , 101 A. 2d 814 , neither of which was shown here. Order affirmed, appellee to pay the costs.