Maryland case law › Bailey v. State

Bailey v. State

429 Md. 524 (2012) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Dismissed✓ Good law
SummaryThis case arises from an order of the Court of Appeals of Maryland addressing a jurisdictional question. Bailey filed a Motion for a New Trial Upon Newly Discovered Exculpatory Evidence in the Circuit Court for Prince George's County on February 26, 2010. The Circuit Court denied the motion by order dated March 3, 2011. Bailey then attempted to take a direct appeal to the Court of Appeals, which the State moved to dismiss. The Court of Appeals granted the motion to dismiss, holding that it lacked jurisdiction under Md. Code, Crim. Proc. Art., § 8-201, because the motion did not seek DNA testing of any evidence. The Court further ordered that the case be remanded to the Court of Special Appeals with instructions to: (a) vacate its prior order transferring the case to the Court of Appeals; (b) consider and decide Bailey's motion as if it were an application for leave to appeal from the den
Questions presented
  • Whether the Court of Appeals has jurisdiction to entertain a direct appeal under Md. Code, Crim. Proc. Art., § 8-201, from the denial of a motion for a new trial upon newly discovered exculpatory evidence that does not seek DNA testing.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

ORDER Upon consideration of the briefs, record, and oral argument in the above case, it is this 5th day of December, 2012, ORDERED, by the Court of Appeals of Maryland, that the State’s Motion to Dismiss this direct appeal be, and the same is hereby, granted, there being no jurisdiction in the Court to entertain a direct appeal to the Court of Appeals, under Md.Code, Crim. Proc. Art., § 8-201, from the denial by the 525 Circuit Court for Prince George’s County (as reflected in its Order of March 3, 2011) of Bailey’s Motion for a New Trial Upon Newly Discovered Exculpatory Evidence filed in the circuit court on February 26, 2010, which motion does not seek DNA testing of any evidence; and, it is further ORDERED, that this case be remanded to the Court of Special Appeals to: (a) vacate its Order of May 3, 2012, transferring this case to the Court of Appeals as a direct appeal cognizable under § 8-201; (b) consider and decide Bailey’s aforesaid Motion for a New Trial Upon Newly Discovered Exculpatory Evidence as if it were an application for leave to appeal from the denial of a request to reopen post-conviction proceedings; and, (c) subject to the Court of Special Appeals’s consideration and action on said motion, remand the case ultimately to the Circuit Court for Prince George’s County for the purpose of the Circuit Court considering and acting on Bailey’s Motion for Release of Evidence to Conduct DNA Analysis, filed on July 1, 2010, which appears never to have been ruled upon by the Circuit Court; and, it is further ORDERED, that costs in this Court be, and the same are, hereby waived.