Maryland case law › Bell v. Purvis

Bell v. Purvis

15 Md. 22 (1860) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: ReversedEccleston, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis appeal arose from an order of the Circuit Court for Baltimore City granting an injunction in favor of the appellees (Purvis et al.) against the appellant (Bell). The bill praying for the injunction was filed on April 13, 1859, and a subpoena was issued returnable the second Monday of May. The defendant appeared on April 15 and filed his answer on May 6. Twelve days after the answer was filed, the court passed an order granting the injunction. The defendant appealed from that order. The Court of Appeals, speaking through Eccleston, J., framed the issue as whether an injunction should be granted after the defendant has already filed an answer denying the equity of the bill. The court reasoned that if an answer denying the equity had been filed after the injunction was granted, it would have authorized a dissolution of the injunction upon a motion to dissolve. Because the answer came i
Questions presented
  • Whether an injunction should be granted after the defendant has filed an answer denying the equity of the bill.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Eccleston, J., delivered the opinion of this court. This bill, praying for an injunction, was filed in the Circuit Court for Baltimore city, on the 13th of April 1859, by the appellees against the appellant. A subpoena was issued, returnable the second Monday of May following. The defendant appeared the 15th of April and filed his answer on the 6th of May.

Twelve days after, the court passed an order granting an injunction; from which order the present appeal was taken. The answer denies the equity of the bill; and if the injunction had been granted, and such an answer had been subsequently filed, it would have authorized a dissolution of the injunction, upon a motion to dissolve. If this be true, then, inasmuch as the answer came in before the injunction was ordered, it should not have been granted. Hall vs. McPherson, 3 Bland’s Ch.

Rep.,529. 3 Danl. Ch. Pr., 1813, 1814, (Ed. 1846.) Order reversed and cause remanded,