Maryland case law › Bisesi v. Director of Patuxent Institution

Bisesi v. Director of Patuxent Institution

243 Md. 605 (1966) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: DeniedHorney, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThomas V. Bisesi was convicted of burglary and larceny in 1962 and sentenced to eighteen months in the Maryland State Reformatory for Males. In 1963 he was found to be a defective delinquent and committed to Patuxent Institution. On December 29, 1964, a petition for redetermination was filed. After a hearing without a jury, the lower court on April 5, 1965, found Bisesi still a defective delinquent and recommitted him. Bisesi applied for leave to appeal, raising six contentions: (1) the evidence was legally insufficient; (2) the only State witness was Dr. Harold M. Boslow; (3) Boslow's testimony was based on conclusions of other staff members; (4) Bisesi had been improving at Patuxent; (5) an aunt could obtain a job for him; and (6) the tests used to determine defective delinquency were irregular and inconclusive. The Court of Appeals treated all contentions as challenges to the legal su
Questions presented
  • Whether the evidence was legally sufficient to support a finding of defective delinquency.
  • Whether the testimony of Dr. Harold M. Boslow, the only State witness, based on conclusions of other staff members, was sufficient to support the finding.
  • Whether the applicant's improvement at Patuxent and the possibility of employment through his aunt affected the legal sufficiency of the evidence.
  • Whether the tests given to determine defective delinquency were irregular and inconclusive.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Horney, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. This is an application for leave to appeal from an order of the lower court dated April 5, 1965, recommitting Thomas V. Bisesi to Patuxent Institution after a determination by the court, sitting without a jury, that he was still a defective delinquent within the meaning of § 5 of Art. 3IB (1965 Cum. Supp.). The applicant had previously been convicted of burglary and larceny and sentenced on March 9, 1962 to a term of eighteen 606 months in the Maryland State Reformatory for Males.

Subsequently, on February 1, 1963, the applicant was found to be a defective delinquent and was committed to Patuxent. The petition for a redetermination of the status of the applicant was filed on December 29, 1964. In this application for leave to appeal filed on his behalf by his attorney, the applicant contends: (1) that the evidence was legally insufficient to support a finding of defective delinquency; (2) that the only witness for the State was Dr. Harold M. Boslow; (3) that his testimony was based on the conclusions of other staff members at Patuxent; (4) that the applicant had been improving at Patuxent; (5) that an aunt of the applicant could obtain a job for him; and (6) that the tests given to determine whether he was a defective delinquent were irregular and inconclusive. . AH of the. contentions concern the legal sufficiency of the evidence.

In that situation, when the case has been tried by the court without a jury the judgment of the court will not be set aside on the evidence unless clearly erroneous. Alt v. Director, 240 Md. 262 , 213 A. 2d 746 (1965) ; Johns v. Director, 239 Md. 411 , 211 A. 2d 751 (1965). The record in this case indicates that the finding of the lower court was not clearly erroneous. Specifically, in Alt and again, in Murel v. Director, 240 Md. 258 , 213 A. 2d 576 (1965), it was held that conclusions of the staff, including the director, constitute a sufficient basis for the finding of defective delinquency.

Contentions such as the fourth and fifth as to the, rehabilitation of an applicant also concern (as did the first, second and third contentions) the legal sufficiency of the evidence. See Silvestri v. Director, 234 Md. 641 , 199 A. 2d 784 (1964). The sixth contention that the tests were irregular and inconclusive was based only on a bald and meaningless assertion of fact that such tests were made at varying intervals and by different testers. Application denied.