Maryland case law › Bostock v. Sams

Bostock v. Sams

95 Md. 745 (1902) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: AffirmedJones, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThe appellants filed a bill in the Circuit Court of Baltimore City seeking an injunction based on the same facts that supported a petition for mandamus in a companion case (No. 53). The circuit court dismissed the bill without prejudice. On appeal, the Court of Appeals had already determined in No. 53 that the appellants had a full and effective remedy at law by way of mandamus. The sole question before the Court in this case was whether the appellants might also obtain injunctive relief as a cumulative remedy. Because the appellants had already obtained full redress through mandamus, the Court deemed the question moot. The Court affirmed the dismissal, holding that the circuit court had at least discretion to deny the injunction because the plaintiffs had a full and effective remedy at law. The Court expressly declined to express any further views on the availability of injunction as a
Questions presented
  • Whether the appellants might also have had relief by way of injunction as a cumulative remedy.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Opinion by Jones, J., 745 In this case the appellants applied to the Circuit Court of Baltimore City for an injunction upon the facts set out in their bill. These facts are the same as those set out in a petition for mandamus in case No. 53 on the docket of the present term of this Court. The Court below dismissed the bill for an injunction without prejudice. We have determined in No. 53 746 ante p. 400, that the appellants had for the grounds of complaint set out in their bill for an injunction an effective remedy by way of mandamus.

The only question we are called upon now therefore to determine in the. present case is whether the appellants might also have had relief by way of injunction as a cumulative remedy. The appellants having obtained full redress in their proceeding upon mandamus this becomes a moot question. We will therefore affirm the decree of the Court below without any expression of views further than to say that the Court below had at least a discretion under the circumstances of the case to deny an injunction for the reason that the plaintiffs in the injunction suit had a full and effective remedy at law.