Maryland case law › Bowie v. Warden

Bowie v. Warden

190 Md. 728 (1947) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: Denied✓ Good law
SummaryBowie filed an application for leave to appeal from the refusal of a writ of habeas corpus. He was imprisoned under a life sentence for rape. He alleged that he was illegally arrested without a warrant and held for two days before charges were placed against him, and that the court erroneously admitted evidence (not stated) 'purporting to sustain' the accusations against him without 'documentary proof.' The Court of Appeals, in a brief per curiam opinion, denied the application. The Court held that even if Bowie was illegally arrested and held, he did not thereby obtain absolution from punishment when lawfully indicted, tried, and convicted. The Court further held that procedural details, including rulings on evidence, are not fundamental and cannot be reviewed on habeas corpus. The Court cited Davis v. Brady, Warden, 188 Md. 113, 51 A.2d 827, and Edmondson v. Brady, 188 Md. 96, 52 A.2d
Questions presented
  • Whether an illegal arrest and detention without a warrant for two days before charges were placed absolves a defendant from punishment when later lawfully indicted, tried, and convicted?
  • Whether procedural details, including rulings on evidence, can be reviewed on habeas corpus?
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

This is an application for leave to appeal from refusal of a writ of habeas corpus. Jackson v. Warden of Maryland House of Correction, 190 Md. 717 , 60 A.2d 179 , just decided. Petitioner is imprisoned under sentence for life for rape. He alleges that he was illegally arrested without a warrant and held for two days before charges were placed against him and that the court erroneously admitted *Page 729 evidence (not stated) "purporting to sustain" the accusations against him without "documentary proof".

Even if he was illegally arrested and held, he did not thereby obtain absolution from punishment when lawfully indicted, tried and convicted. Davis v. Brady, Warden, 188 Md. 113 , 51 A.2d 827 ; Edmondson v. Brady, 188 Md. 96 , 52 A.2d 96 . Procedural details (not fundamental), including rulings on evidence, cannot be reviewed on habeas corpus. Olewiler v. Brady, 185 Md. 341 , 344, 44 A.2d 807 .

Application denied, without costs .