Maryland case law › Bowie v. Warden of Maryland Penitentiary

Bowie v. Warden of Maryland Penitentiary

230 Md. 607 (1962) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Remanded✓ Good law
SummaryIn this post conviction proceeding, the petitioner, convicted on the second count of an indictment, contended that the second count charged rape rather than assault with intent to rape, and that since he was acquitted on the first count charging rape, his conviction on the second count violated the rule against double jeopardy and was illegal and unconstitutional as being for an offense not charged. The Court noted that the double jeopardy point had been finally litigated in Bowie v. Warden, 201 Md. 648, although Chief Judge Markell had remarked that the indictment was not in the record, and cited Plater v. Warden, 220 Md. 673. On the claim of illegal sentence, Judge Manley in the court below stated that the petitioner's assertion that he was found guilty of assault with intent to rape was contrary to the record. However, the docket entries showed that he was convicted of assault with in
Questions presented
  • Whether the second count of the indictment, upon which petitioner was convicted, charged rape rather than assault with intent to rape, and whether the conviction on the second count was illegal and unconstitutional, being for an offense not charged therein.
  • Whether the rule against double jeopardy barred the conviction on the second count after acquittal on the first count charging rape.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Per Curiam. In this application for leave to appeal from a denial of post conviction relief, the only point raised by the petitioner that is worthy of discussion is his claim that the second count of the indictment, upon which he was convicted, charged rape rather than assault with intent to rape. Since he was acquitted 608 on the first count charging rape, he invokes the rule against double jeopardy, as well as contending that the conviction on the second count was illegal and unconstitutional, being for an offense not charged therein. The point as to double jeopardy was finally litigated in Bowie v. Warden, 201 Md. 648 , although Chief Judge Markell, for this Court, remarked that the indictment was not in the record.

Cf. Plater v. Warden, 220 Md. 673 . On the point of illegal sentence Judge Manley, in the court below, stated that “the statement by the petitioner that he was found guilty of assault with intent to rape is contrary to the record.” Yet the docket entries show that he was convicted of assault with intent to rape, and the second count was at least ambiguous in form. Under the circumstances we are constrained to remand the case for further consideration of that point by Judge Manley, without affirmance or reversal.

We intimate no opinion as to whether the point was finally litigated in Bowie v. Warden, supra, or whether a defect in the indictment could be reviewed in this proceeding. Leave to appeal granted and case remanded without affirmance or reversal for further proceedings.