Maryland case law › Broening v. Haley

Broening v. Haley

156 Md. 605 (1929) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: Reversed✓ Good law
SummaryBroening v. Haley was an appeal from an order overruling a demurrer to a bill of complaint seeking an injunction to restrain city officials from passing an ordinance that would change the zoning classification of an area, thereby preventing the complainant landowner from proceeding with building plans conforming to the prior zoning. The bill also sought to prevent the dissolution of a previously issued injunction. The landowner attacked the proposed ordinance on several grounds: that it would be an arbitrary and unreasonable exercise of power not possessed by the city, that it would be invalid because it operated upon a single individual landowner, that it would usurp judicial functions by the legislative body, and that its passage would cause irreparable damage. In essence, the injunction was sought on the ground that the ordinance would be invalid if passed. The Court of Appeals, in a
Questions presented
  • Whether a court of equity may interfere in advance, by injunction, to restrain the passage of an allegedly invalid ordinance, on the ground of its invalidity if passed.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

The following opinion was delivered per Curiam: The appeal is from an order overruling a demurrer to a bill of complaint for an injunction to restrain the passage by the city officials of an ordinance changing the nature of an 606 area under the zoning plan, so that the complainant, a landowner in that area, could not proceed with plans for building in accordance with previous zoning of the area, and refusing to dissolve an injunction previously issued. The proposed ordinance is attacked on the grounds that it would constitute an attempt to exercise arbitrary, unreasonable powers not possessed by the city, that it would be invalid because of its actual operation upon a single individual landowner, that it would be a usurpation of a judicial function by the city legislative body, and that its passage would irreparably damage the landowner. In short, the ordinance is attacked, and the injunction against its passage is sought, on the ground of its invalidity if passed. Only in a few rare and exceptional cases could a court interfere in advance in this way with the exercise of the power of legislation.

The regular method of resisting an invalid exercise of that power is by enjoining enforcement after passage. 4 Pomeroy, Equity (4th Ed.), sec. 1764; New Orleans Water Works v. New Orleans, 164 U. S. 471 . At least, it would seem, the case should be one in which the mere placing of the law on the statute books causes by itself an injustice which the courts are required to prevent; and that does not appear to be the case here. In the opinion of this court no exceptional situation, such as has sometimes been held to support anticipatory judicial interference, is-presented here; and the demurrer should have been sustained and the bill dismissed. Order reversed and bill dismissed, with costs to> the appellants.