Maryland case law › Brooke v. Macnemara

Brooke v. Macnemara

1 Md. 80 (1728) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: Affirmed✓ Good law
SummaryThis was an action of debt on a bond executed by the defendant's father to the plaintiff, with a condition to save the plaintiff harmless for paying a debt due by the father to one Carlton. The defendant pleaded that the plaintiff was not damnified. The plaintiff replied that an attachment against Carlton was laid in the hands of the plaintiff as garnishee, and a condemnation was had thereon. The defendant demurred generally. The Court adjudged the replication good, and that judgment was affirmed on appeal to the Court of Appeals at May Term, 1729. The defendant then appealed to the King in Council. The opinion is a brief note by S. Chase and does not set forth the court's reasoning, the legal questions as framed by the court, or any verbatim holdings. It contains only a skeletal recitation of the pleadings and the procedural disposition.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

THIS was an action of debt on a bond to the plaintiff by the defendant’s father, with a condition to save the plaintiff harmless, for paying a debt due by him to one Carlton. The defendant pleaded that the plaintiff was not damnified. Replication. That an attachment against Carlton was laid in the hands of the plaintiff as garnishee, and a condemnation was had thereon.

General demurrer. The Court adjudged the replication good, which judgment was affirmed on an appeal to the Court of Appeals, at May Term, 1729. The defendant then appealed to the King in Council. S. Chase's notes.