Maryland case law › Brooks v. State

Brooks v. State

312 Md. 115 (1988) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Reversed✓ Good law
SummaryThe Court of Appeals granted certiorari and summarily reversed the judgment of the Circuit Court for Baltimore City. The undisputed facts showed that a District Court judge revoked Petitioner Oceola Bertha Brooks's probation following her conviction for driving under the influence of alcohol. Brooks appealed and requested a trial de novo in the Circuit Court for Baltimore City. The same District Court judge, who had been specially assigned to preside over cases in the Circuit Court for a designated time period, presided at Brooks's circuit court trial over her objection. The Court of Appeals determined that it was improper for the same judge to preside at the circuit court de novo trial on appeal from the District Court. The Court cited the Maryland Constitution, Article IV, § 15, Maryland Rule 1231, and the Code of Judicial Conduct, Canon 3C(1). The judgment was summarily reversed and t
Questions presented
  • Whether it was improper for the same judge who revoked probation in the District Court to preside at the circuit court de novo trial on appeal from the District Court.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

ORDER PER CURIAM. The Court having considered and granted the petition for a writ of certiorari, in the above entitled case, and The Court having found from the undisputed facts that at a hearing in the District Court of Maryland, the presiding judge revoked probation imposed upon the Petitioner, Oceola Bertha Brooks, following her conviction for driving under the influence of alcohol and that thereafter Petitioner appealed this decision and requested a trial de novo in the Circuit Court for Baltimore City, and It appearing that the presiding judge in the District Court having been specially assigned to preside over cases in the Circuit Court for Baltimore City for a designated time period, presided at Petitioner’s circuit court trial, over Petitioner’s objection, and The Court having determined that it was improper for the same judge to preside at Petitioner’s circuit court de novo 117 trial on appeal from the District Court, it is this 10th day of March, 1988 ORDERED, by the Court of Appeals of Maryland, that the judgment of the Circuit Court for Baltimore City, No. 38711893 be, and it is hereby, summarily reversed and the case remanded to the Circuit Court for Baltimore City for a new trial. See, e.g., Maryland Constitution, Article IV § 15; Md.Rule 1231 Code of Judicial Conduct, Canon 3C(1). Costs to be paid by the Mayor and City Council of Baltimore.