Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: AffirmedLe Grand, C. J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case came before the Court of Appeals on appeal from a decree of the Chancellor. The appellant, Brooks, sought relief from a conveyance or transfer of property to Thomas, alleging that Thomas was insolvent and that the transaction was fraudulent. The Chancellor dismissed the bill, and Brooks appealed. The majority of the Court of Appeals affirmed the Chancellor's decree. Chief Judge Le Grand dissented, delivering an opinion in which he concurred with the Chancellor's decree but expressed sympathy for the appellant. The dissent noted that, apart from the strict rules of evidence, the appellant would be entitled to relief because it was impossible to suppose that Thomas, given his close and intimate relation to the appellant and the taking of all his property, was unaware of his insolvent condition. However, because Mr. Jerome denied knowledge of Thomas's insolvency and was not contra
Le Grand, C. J., dissented, and delivered the following opinion: I have carefully examined this case and concur in the correctness of the decree of the chancellor, and for the reasons assigned by him. I feel bound to say, however, that it is a case — apart from the stern rules prescribed by the law of evidence for the interpretation of the motives of parties — entitling the appellant to the relief sought by him; for it is impossible to suppose — when his close and intimate relation to Thomas is considered and the taking of all his property — that he was not aware of his insolvent condition; a fact which, according to the testimony of Mr. Evans, seems to have been generally believed. But Mr. Jerome denies such knowledge, and he is not contradicted as fully and in the way required by the law, and as a consequence, his denial prevails.