Maryland case law › Brown v. Ellicott

Brown v. Ellicott

2 Md. 75 (1852) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: AffirmedLe Grand, C.J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis was an action in which the plaintiff sought to recover for wharfage. The defendant requested an instruction that the plaintiff was not entitled to recover because the wharf in question was a public wharf. The county court refused to grant the instruction. The Court of Appeals affirmed, holding that the instruction was defective because it took the factual question of whether the wharf was public from the jury. The Court emphasized that the sufficiency of evidence to establish a fact is for the jury, and a court may not direct a jury that evidence proves a fact even if all evidence is on one side. The Court declined to intimate whether the theory of the prayer was correct, resting its decision solely on the defect that the instruction removed the factual determination from the jury. The judgment was affirmed.
Questions presented
  • Whether the county court erred in refusing to grant the defendant's instruction that the plaintiff was not entitled to recover for wharfage because the wharf was a public wharf.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Le Giiaxd, C. J., delivered the opinion of the court.- We discover no error in the refusal of the-county court to grant the instruction asked by the defendant. The hypothesis of the prayer was, that the plaintiff was not entitled to recover for wharfage, because, the wharf alluded to in the proof was a public wharf, and yet it look the fact, whether it was a public wharf, from the finding of the jury. 82 We do- not deem it proper to intimate, whether or not the theory-of the prayer is correct, it being clearly defective- in the particular to whieh we-have referred. Reagan vs. Gaither, 11 Gill and Johnson, 479. In the case-of the Charleston Insurance and Trust Co. vs. Corner, 2 Gill, 426 , ’7, the Court of Appeals say :• “Doubtless the jury would have found these facts according to- the testimony, but the sufficiency of evidence to satisfy a jury, or the circumstance, that it is all on one side, does not authorise the court to direct the jury that it proves the fact.

They have the power to refuse their credit, and no action of the court should control the exercise of their admitted right, to weigh the credibility of evidence.” See*, also, Grove vs. Brien, Ex’cr, &c., December term, 1851. Judgment affirmed.