Maryland case law › Buettner v. Superintendent of the Maryland Correctional Institution for Women

Buettner v. Superintendent of the Maryland Correctional Institution for Women

239 Md. 710 (1965) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: DeniedPer Curiam✓ Good law
SummaryThe applicant, convicted of first degree murder in 1963 and sentenced to life imprisonment, filed a petition for post conviction relief under the Uniform Post Conviction Procedure Act after her direct appeal was affirmed in Buettner v. State, 233 Md. 235. The petition was denied by Judge Cullen after a hearing. The applicant sought leave to appeal but failed to comply with Maryland Rule BK46 b, which requires an application for leave to appeal to contain a brief statement of the reasons why the lower court's order should be reversed or modified. The Court of Appeals dismissed the application on this procedural ground, citing Greene v. Warden, Thompson v. Warden, and Dofflemyer v. Director. The Court further noted that even if Rule BK46 b had been complied with, the application would be denied because the only contention pressed below—that certain evidence was the product of an illegal se
Questions presented
  • Whether the application for leave to appeal must be dismissed for failure to comply with Maryland Rule BK46 b, which requires a brief statement of reasons why the lower court's order should be reversed or modified.
  • Whether the applicant's contention that evidence was the product of an illegal search and seizure could be raised in a post conviction proceeding when it had already been decided on direct appeal.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Per Curiam. The applicant was convicted in the Criminal Court of Baltimore in 1963 of first degree murder and sentenced to life imprisonment in the Maryland Correctional Institution for Women. She appealed to this Court and we affirmed in Buettner v. State, 233 Md. 235 . She then filed a petition for relief 711 under the Uniform Post Conviction Procedure Act, which was denied by Judge Cullen after a hearing.

The applicant has made no attempt whatsoever to comply with Maryland Rule BK46 b, which requires that an application for leave to appeal contain a brief statement of the reasons why the lower court’s order should be reversed or modified. Therefore, the application must be dismissed. Greene v. Warden, 238 Md. 651 ; Thompson v. Warden, 237 Md. 655 ; Dofflemyer v. Director, 237 Md. 639 . However, we would have to deny the application even if Rule BK46 b had been complied with since, according to Judge Cullen’s memorandum opinion, the only contention pressed in the hearing below related to certain evidence which was allegedly the product of an illegal search and seizure.

This question was decided on the applicant’s direct appeal, Buettner v. State, supra, and therefore could not be raised again in a post conviction proceeding. Code (1964 Cum. Supp.), Art. 27, sec. 645A(a); Bryant v. Warden, 235 Md. 658 . Application denied.