Maryland case law › Burrell v. Lamm

Burrell v. Lamm

67 Md. 580 (1887) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: DismissedStone, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case arose from a landlord-tenant dispute in Harford County, Maryland. The landlord instituted proceedings before a justice of the peace under the Act of 1882, chapter 855, to recover possession of leased premises from a tenant holding over after the expiration of the term. The justice of the peace entered judgment in favor of the landlord, and the tenant appealed to the Circuit Court for Harford County. The Circuit Court affirmed the judgment of the justice. The tenant then sought review in the Court of Appeals by writ of error. The Court of Appeals, speaking through Judge Stone, quashed the writ of error. The Court held that where jurisdiction is conferred upon a justice of the peace and an appeal is provided to the Circuit Court, the judgment of the Circuit Court is final, and no appeal lies to the Court of Appeals from the Circuit Court in such a case. The Court recognized a nar
Questions presented
  • Whether a writ of error lies to the Court of Appeals from a judgment of the Circuit Court affirming a judgment of a justice of the peace in a case where jurisdiction was conferred upon the justice of the peace and an appeal to the Circuit Court was provided.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Stone, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. This is a writ of error from the Circuit Court for Harford County. The case is this: Proceedings were instituted before a justice of the peace for that county, by a landlord against his tenant, under the Act of 1882, chapter 855, to recover possession of the leased premises. The justice gave judgment in favor of the landlord, and the tenant appealed to the Circuit Court for Harford County, and the judgment of the justice was affirmed by that Court.

The tenant then brought the case here, upon a writ of error from the Circuit Court for Harford County. The writ'of error in this case must be quashed. Where jurisdiction is given to a justice of the peace, and an appeal to the Circuit Court, the judgment of the Circuit Court is final, and no appeal lies to this Court from the Circuit Court in such a casé. An exception to this rule is found in the case of a justice of the peace, who had no jurisdiction over the case tried before him.

In such a case a writ of error or appeal might lie to this Court from the Circuit Court, to ■which an appeal from the justice had been taken. 582 (Decided 3rd November, 1887.) The writ of error is allowed in such case to this Court,. not for the purpose of correcting an erroneous judgment, hut for the purpose of restraining an inferior tribunal from exercising a jurisdiction, to which it was not entitled by law. But such is not this case. The Act of 1882, chapter 355, gives to a single justice of the peace the jurisdiction to hear and determine cases between landlords, and tenants holding over after the expiration of their terms. This statute requires the landlord to make his complaint in writing to the justice.

This complaint must state, in substance, that the landlord had rented or leased certain property to the tenant for a term that has then ended; that he had given the tenant notice in writing to quit, such as the law requires in his particular case, and that the tenant- had not complied with .it. When these allegations are made, the jurisdiction to hear and determine the case, is vested in the justice. Now, every statement in writing required by the Act of' 1882, chapter 355, and its amendment, the Act of 1886, chapter 470, to be made by the landlord, has been made in this case with • great precision and certainty, and the justice had full power and authority to hear and determine the case. If the judgment of the justice was erroneous, it could only he corrected by the Circuit Court for Harford County, whose judgment is final.

Writ of error quashed.