Maryland case law › Calhoun v. Hall
Calhoun v. Hall
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: Other✓ Good law
SummaryThis brief opinion from the Maryland General Court concerns a boundary dispute involving a red oak and another oak tree, the location of Cole's Harbour, and the scope of a grant to Lunn's Lot. The plaintiff alleged that the red oak and the other oak stood as represented in the pleadings. The court instructed the jury that if those trees were proved to the jury's satisfaction to have stood as the plaintiff alleged, then the boundary course should run from one tree to the other without regard to distance or reference to Cole's Harbour. However, the court further instructed the jury that if the defendant's location of Cole's Harbour was true, then the grant of Lunn's Lot did not pass any land included within Cole's Harbour. The opinion is signed by Johnson, Ch. J., and Goldsborough, J., with Cooke for the plaintiff and Martin (Attorney-General) for the defendant. The text is fragmentary and
Questions presented
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →- Whether, if the red oak and the other oak were proved to have stood as represented and alleged by the plaintiff, the course should be from one to the other of them, without regarding the distance or reference to Cole's Harbour?
- Whether, if the defendant's location of Cole's Harbour was true, the grant of Lunn's Lot did not pass any land included therein?
But the Court of of opinion, and directed the Jury, that in rsase 418 the said red oak and the other oak were proved to their sat # 1 tisfaction to have stood as represented and alleged by the plaintiff, that then the course should be from the one to the other of them, without regarding the distance or reference to Cole’s Harbour; yet the Court were of opinion, and declared to the Jury, that if the defendant’s said location of Cole’s Harbour was true, that then the grant of Lunn’s Lol did not pass any land included therein. (Johnson, Ch. J. and Goldsboeoucic. J.) Cooke, for the plaintiff.
Martin, (Attorney-General,) for the defendant.