Maryland case law › Calvert v. Carter

Calvert v. Carter

6 Md. 135 (1854) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: AffirmedEccleston, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case came before the Court of Appeals on appeal from a decree of the Chancellor. The appellant, Calvert, challenged an arbitration award that the appellee, Carter, sought to enforce. The arbitrators had included in their award matters connected with what was called the 'paternal succession.' The appellant argued that the arbitrators exceeded their authority by including these matters. The Court of Appeals declined to reach that question, stating it was unnecessary to express any opinion on whether the arbitrators exceeded their authority. Instead, the Court fully concurred with the Chancellor that the award lacked certainty, which 'removes it from the way of the plaintiff in this case.' The Court cited additional authorities supporting the Chancellor's reasoning on the certainty point: Waite v. Barry, 12 Wend. 380; Hewitt v. Hewitt, 1 Adol. & Ellis (N.S.) 110, 41 Eng. C.L. Rep. 460;
Questions presented
  • Whether the arbitrators exceeded their authority by including in their award matters which are said to be connected with what is called the 'paternal succession.'
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Eccleston, J., delivered the opinion of this court. We consider it unnecessary to express any opinion in relation to the .question, whether the arbitrators exceeded their authority, by including in their award matters which are said to be connected with what is called the “paternal succession; ” because we fully concur with the chancellor in the opinion, that want of certainty in the award “removes it from the way of the plaintiff in this case.” In addition to what has been so well said by the chancellor on this point, see 12 Wend., 380 , Waite vs. Barry. 1 Adol. & Ellis, (N. S.,) 110, in 41 Eng. C. L. Rep., 460, Hewitt vs. Hewitt. 6 Grattan, 381, Cauthorn vs. Courtney. 142 We affirm the decree of the chancellor, with costs to the appellee, and the cause will be sent to the circuit court for Prince Georges county for further proceedings. For which purpose a decree will be signed in accordance with this decision.

Decree affirmed and cause remanded.