Maryland case law › Campbell v. State

Campbell v. State

231 Md. 21 (1963) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Affirmed✓ Good law
SummaryIn a non-jury trial, the Circuit Court convicted the appellant of armed robbery and carrying a deadly weapon. Three witnesses positively identified him as one of two men who rifled a restaurant cash register at revolver point. The appellant presented an alibi witness who placed him elsewhere, but the trial court, sitting without a jury, credited the State's witnesses. On appeal, the appellant challenged the sufficiency of the evidence and claimed error in the trial court's refusal to appoint substitute counsel. The Court of Appeals held that the evidence was sufficient under Maryland Rule 886 and Knuckles v. State, 228 Md. 318, because the trial court was entitled to believe the three identifying witnesses over the alibi witness. As to the request for new counsel, the Court held that an indigent defendant must accept court-appointed counsel absent a substantial reason for replacement, an
Questions presented
  • Whether the evidence was sufficient to convict the appellant of armed robbery and carrying a deadly weapon.
  • Whether the trial court erred in refusing the appellant's request for appointment of another attorney in lieu of his court-appointed counsel.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Per Curiam. This record reveals no ground whatsoever to support appel 22 lant’s claim of insufficiency of evidence to convict him of armed robbery and carrying a deadly weapon. Three witnesses positively identified him as one of two men who rifled the cash register in a restaurant at revolver point. The trial court in this non-jury case was entitled to believe them, rather than an alibi witness who placed appellant elsewhere.

Maryland Rule 886; Knuckles v. State, 228 Md. 318 . Prior to his trial appellant requested the court to appoint another attorney in lieu of his court-appointed counsel, but, when asked whether there was any good reason for a change in lawyers, he replied: “That is all right.” He now claims error in the refusal of his request. In the absence of any substantial reason for replacement of counsel (none was advanced here), an indigent defendant must accept counsel appointed by the court, unless he desires to present his own defense. Brown v. United States, 264 F. 2d 363, 367 (D.C. Cir.); cf. Murray v. Director, 228 Md. 658, 660 .

But even if the question raised had any merit, it was plainly waived by appellant. Judgments affirmed.