Maryland case law › Carroll v. Warden

Carroll v. Warden

222 Md. 618 (1993) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Denied✓ Good law
SummaryCarroll filed a petition for post conviction relief under the Maryland Post Conviction Procedure Act, challenging his conviction primarily on the ground that the evidence was insufficient to convict. He also complained that he was not given a transcript of his original trial testimony. The Court of Appeals, in a per curiam opinion, held that insufficiency of the evidence is not a ground for post conviction relief, citing Banks v. Warden, 221 Md. 592, 155 A.2d 697. As to the transcript claim, the Court noted that the petitioner did not allege that he requested a transcript, that he sought an appeal and was prevented from perfecting it due to the denial of a transcript, or that he was otherwise hindered. The Court concluded that the application showed no grounds for relief under the Post Conviction Procedure Act and denied the application for leave to appeal.
Questions presented
  • Whether the alleged insufficiency of the evidence to convict is a ground for post conviction relief.
  • Whether the failure to provide a transcript of the original trial testimony entitles the petitioner to post conviction relief.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

222 Md. 618 (1960) 159 A.2d 851 CARROLL v. WARDEN OF MARYLAND PENITENTIARY [P.C. No. 93, September Term, 1959.] Court of Appeals of Maryland. Decided April 18, 1960. Before BRUNE, C.J., and HENDERSON, HAMMOND and HORNEY, JJ. PER CURIAM: The petitioner's contentions deal mainly with the alleged insufficiency of the evidence to convict, which is not a ground for post conviction relief.

Banks v. Warden, 221 Md. 592 , 155 A.2d 697 . Although he complains that he was not given a transcript of the testimony of his original trial, there is no allegation that he either requested such a transcript or that he sought an appeal and was prevented from perfecting it as a result of being denied the transcript, or otherwise. His application to the lower court shows no grounds for relief under 619 the Post Conviction Procedure Act, and his application for leave to appeal is denied. Application denied.