Maryland case law › Carvill's Lessee v. Griffith

Carvill's Lessee v. Griffith

1 Md. 297 (1769) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Reversed✓ Good law
SummaryThis brief opinion addresses whether a grantee of the Crown may invoke the King's prerogative to choose the court in which to sue. The court explains that while the King has an election to sue in whatever court he pleases, that privilege is personal to the Crown and cannot be communicated or assigned to a subject, even by express words. The rule operates only vice versa: when the King purchases lands from a subject, he retains his prerogatives and suffers no diminution of them, but a subject receiving a grant from the Crown cannot partake of those royal privileges. The court thus rejects the argument that the King's election passes to his grantee. The Court of Appeals at February Term 1772 reversed the judgment of the Provincial Court, though the text does not specify the underlying facts or the precise procedural mechanism beyond that reversal.
Questions presented
  • Whether the grantee of the King has the same privilege as the King to elect in what court he pleases to sue.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

It has been said that the King has an election to sue in what Court he pleases; but that is no argument, to say that the grantee of the King has the same privilege, for the King cannot communicate or assign it even by express words ; but the rule is vice versa, for where the King purchases lands of a subject, he shall hold it without any diminution of his privileges ; but the subject cannot partake of them in any grant of lands from the crown. The Court of Appeals at February Term, 1772, reversed the judgment of the Provincial Court.