Maryland case law › Chauvenet v. Commissioners

Chauvenet v. Commissioners

3 Md. 259 (1852) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: ReversedLe Grand, C. J.✓ Good law
SummaryThe appellant, an officer of the United States government residing within the limits of jurisdiction ceded to the federal government, was assessed by the commissioners of Anne Arundel County for personal property taxes. He challenged the assessment, relying on the second section of the act of 1847, chapter 158, which exempts from all state taxes and assessments the lands and personal property within the ceded jurisdiction belonging to the United States or its officers or agents, so long as the lands remain federal property and are used for the specified purposes. The Court of Appeals, speaking through Chief Judge Le Grand, held that the appellant, as a federal officer residing within the ceded territory, was exempt from the state tax on his personal property. The Court reasoned that the property assessed was personal and followed the situs of the owner, and that the act of 1847 exempted
Questions presented
  • Whether the personal property of a federal officer residing within the limits of jurisdiction ceded to the federal government is exempt from state taxation under the act of 1847, chapter 158.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Le Grand, C. J., delivered the opinion of this court. We think this case is free from all difficulty. The second section of the act of 1847, chapter 158, provides, “that the lands over which the jurisdiction is granted by this act, together with all the personal property which is or may be hereafter, within the bounds thereof, belonging to the United States, or to any of its officers or agents, shall be exonerated and discharged from all taxes and assessments which may be at any time imposed by the authority of this State, so long as the said lands and territories shall remain the property of the United States, and be used for the purposes aforesaid.” It is admitted that the appellant was an officer of the government of the United States at the time of the assessment, and that he resides within the limits of the jurisdiction ceded to the federal government. The property assessed is personal, and, of course, follows the situs of the owner.

The fact that the appellant exercised the right of voting at the general election of 1851, cannot effect his rights in this controversy. If he violated the election laws of the State — but on that subject we express no opinion — he was liable to a prosecution for so doing. The act of 1847 exempts all the personal property of the 265 officers and agents of the federal government, who reside within the prescribed limits, from “all taxes and assessments” which may be “at any time” imposed by the authority of this • State. Language cannot be more explicit or comprehensive.

For these reasons we differ from the opinion of the commissioners of Anne Arundel' county, and in conformity with the requirements of the thirty-second section of the act of 1852, chapter 33T, we direct the clerk of this court to send a Copy of this opinion to the commissioners of said county.