Maryland case law › Cityco Realty Co. v. Slaysman

Cityco Realty Co. v. Slaysman

160 Md. 357 (1931) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: AffirmedBond, C. J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis opinion is a dissenting opinion by Bond, C.J., in Cityco Realty Co. v. Slaysman, 160 Md. 357 (1931). The dissent would have affirmed the decree below and dismissed the bill of complaint. The complainant retained a one-foot strip of land beside a highway, unrelated to any usable land it still owned. The dissent reasoned that this strip is a property right the complainant cannot itself enjoy and that it places the property under the feet of the public and adjacent owners, making disregard and violation of the retained legal interest inevitable. An injunction would protect an unsubstantial interest against inevitable disregard. The element of irreparable damage necessary to support equitable interference seemed lacking, citing Whalen v. Delashmutt, 59 Md. 250, 254. Prevention by injunction was made difficult, if not impracticable, by the complainant's arrangement. The dissent further n
Questions presented
  • Whether an injunction should issue to protect a one-foot strip of land retained by the complainant beside a highway, where the strip is unrelated to any usable land and the complainant's purpose is to exact a price from the adjacent owner for freedom from annoyance and inconvenience.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Bond, C. J., filed a dissenting opinion as follows: In leaving this one-foot strip of its land beside the highway, unrelated to any usable land which the complainant may still own, the complainant has left itself a property right which it cannot itself enjoy, and has placed its property under the feet of the public and adjacent owners, so to speak, with the result that disregard and violation of the legal interest retained seem inevitable. An injunction would seem 368 to protect an unsubstantial interest against inevitable disregard. Tbe element of irreparable damage to tbe complainant, which is necessary to support equitable interference, seems lacking. Whalen v. Delashmutt, 59 Md. 250, 254 .

And prevention by injunction is, by the complainant’s arrangement, made difficult, if not impracticable. When it is added that the complainant’s purpose, in which the aid of the court is enlisted in this case, is to exact from the adjacent owner a price for freedom from annoyance and inconvenience, it seems to me the court of equity is presented with a strong case for refusal to interfere. My conclusion is that the decree should be affirmed and the bill of complaint dismissed. Story, Equity Jurisprudence, secs. 1292 and 1293; 1 High, Injunctions (4th Ed.), sec. 723; 2 Beach, Injunction, sec. 1127.