Maryland case law › Clayland's Lessee v. Pearce
Clayland's Lessee v. Pearce
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Other✓ Good law
SummaryThis case arose on a special verdict in an ejectment action (Clayland's Lessee v. Pearce) in the Provincial Court of Maryland in 1714. The sole question of law reserved for the court was whether the Statute of Frauds and Perjuries, 29 Charles II, applied to invalidate a will made in Maryland. The court noted that the will was executed within two and a half years after the enactment of the English statute, and before the statute had been published or notice thereof given in the Province. Additionally, the Maryland Act of Assembly directing the manner of pleading the laws of England in the Commissary's Court had not yet been passed. The court was also influenced by the fact that this was 'the infancy of the country, when evidences were harder to come by than now.' On these grounds, the court overruled the argument based on the statute and entered judgment for the plaintiff. The court did n
Questions presented
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →- Whether the English Statute of Frauds and Perjuries, 29 Charles II, applied to invalidate a will made in Maryland before the statute was published or notice thereof given in the Province, and before the enactment of the Maryland Act of Assembly directing the manner of pleading the laws of England in the Commissary's Court.
The Court. The matter of law insisted on the special verdict, being only on the act of parliament, relating to frauds and perjuries of 29 Charles II. for that it seemed to the Court, that the will was made within two years and a half after the making of the said statute, and before publication, or notice thereof in this Province, and before the making of the act of Assembly, directing the manner of pleading the laws of England in the Commissary’s Court; and also in the infancy of the country, when evidences were harder to come by than now, the Court were induced 30 by these motives to overrule the argument on the said statute. Judgment for the plaintiff. Lib.
V. D. No. 1. folio 297.