Maryland case law › Cole v. Warden

Cole v. Warden

1 Md. App. 21 (1967) · Court of Special Appeals of Maryland
Court of Special Appeals of MarylandDisposition: DeniedThompson✓ Good law
SummaryCole filed his second petition for post-conviction relief under the Maryland Uniform Post Conviction Procedure Act, contending that Escobedo v. Illinois should be applied retroactively because handwriting specimens obtained from him amounted to a confession, and that he was not advised of his right to remain silent or right to counsel and was denied use of a telephone to obtain counsel. The lower court denied relief after two hearings, finding as a fact that Cole gave the handwriting specimens voluntarily. On application for leave to appeal, Cole sought to avoid the Supreme Court's decision in Johnson v. New Jersey, which held Escobedo non-retroactive, by invoking Davis v. North Carolina, which held that a coerced confession violates due process and may be raised at any time. The Court of Special Appeals held that while Cole's allegations might bring him within Escobedo, they were insuff
Questions presented
  • Whether Escobedo v. Illinois should be applied retroactively to this case because specimens of his handwriting obtained from him amounted to a confession, and he was not advised of his right to remain silent, and he was not advised of his right to counsel, and he was denied the right to use a telephone to obtain counsel.
  • Whether the Petitioner's case falls within the doctrine of Davis v. North Carolina, which held that a coerced confession violated due process and could be raised at any time.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Thompson, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. On July 27, 1962, the Petitioner was found guilty in the Circuit Court for Baltimore County under four indictments for forgery and one indictment for conspiracy, by Judge John E. Raine, Jr., sitting without a jury, and was sentenced to three years consecutive under each of the forgery indictments 22 and eighteen months consecutive for conspiracy. Judgment and sentence was affirmed by the Court of Appeals of Maryland in Cole v. State, 232 Md. 111 , 194 A. 2d 278 , cert. den. 375 U. S. 980 , 11 L. Ed. 2d 425 , 84 S. Ct. 503 (January 6, 1964). The Petitioner filed his first petition for relief under the Uniform Post Conviction Procedure Act on February 5, 1964, which relief was denied by Judge James J. Lindsay on March 23, 1964, and application for leave to appeal therefrom was denied.

Cole v. Warden, 235 Md. 683 , 202 A. 2d 596 . The present petition, being the second application for relief under the Uniform Post Conviction Procedure Act, was filed June 21, 1965. Counsel was thereafter appointed to represent the Petitioner in these proceedings. A hearing was held before the Honorable Walter M. Jenifer on April 12, 1966, and a second hearing on reargument on June 3, 1966, at which time relief was denied.

The burden of the Petitioner’s contention below was that Escobedo v. Illinois, 378 U. S. 478 , 12 L. Ed. 2d 977 , 84 S. Ct. 1758 (June 22, 1964) should be applied retroactively in this case because specimens of his handwriting obtained from him amounted to a confession; and he was not advised of his right to remain silent, and he was not advised of his right to counsel and he was denied the right to use a telephone to obtain counsel. This matter was settled finally by the Supreme Court of the United States on June 20, 1966, in the case of Johnson v. New Jersey, 384 U. S. 719 , 16 L. Ed. 2d 882 , 86 S. Ct. 1772 , which ruled that Escobedo v. Illinois, supra, was not retroactive. In his application for leave to appeal, filed July 6, 1966, the Petitioner, seeking to avoid the effects of Johnson v. New Jersey, supra, attempts to bring his case within the doctrine of Davis v. North Carolina, 384 U. S. 737 , 16 L. Ed. 2d 895 , 86 S. Ct. 1761 (also decided June 20, 1966) which held that a coerced confession violated due process and could be raised at any time. The lower court found as a fact that the Petitioner gave his specimens of handwriting voluntarily.

Although the Petitioner’s allegations would bring the case within Escobedo 23 v. Illinois, supra, they are quite insufficient to bring the Petitioner the protection of Davis v. North Carolina, supra. Application denied.