Maryland case law › Colvin v. Warford

Colvin v. Warford

17 Md. 433 (1861) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: ReversedBartol✓ Good law
SummaryThis appeal arose from a chancery proceeding in which the circuit court granted an injunction and appointed a receiver at the behest of complainants who feared for their interests pending an action of ejectment. The appellant answered the bill, and the answer was responsive to the allegations. The circuit court subsequently refused to dissolve the injunction and refused to rescind the order appointing a receiver. On appeal, the Court of Appeals declined to decide whether the original injunction and receivership were properly granted, finding it unnecessary. Instead, the court held that whatever equity the complainants may have had was taken away by the appellant's answer, which under chancery practice must be taken as true so far as it is responsive to the bill. The court relied on Code, Art. 16, sec. 103, which embodies that rule. Because the answer destroyed the basis for equitable rel
Questions presented
  • Whether the circuit court erred in its subsequent order of July 14, 1860, refusing to dissolve the injunction, continuing the same, and refusing to rescind the order appointing a receiver.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Bartol, J., delivered the opinion of this court. It is unnecessary for this court to determine whether, upon the case stated by the bill of complaint, an injunction was properly granted by the circuit court, and a receiver appointed. We are ail of opinion that there was error in the subsequent order of the 14th of July I860, refusing to dissolve the injunction, and continuing the same, and refusing to rescind the order appointing a receiver. Whatever equity the complainants may have had under their bill, to claim the interposition of the court in their behalf, upon the ground of apprehended danger to their interests, in the event of their ultimate success in the action of ejectment now pending, has been taken away by the answer of the appellant, which, under the rules governing proceedings in chancery, must be taken as true, so far as the same is responsive to the allegations of the bill.

See Code, Art. 16, sec. 103. A decree will be signed reversing the orders of the circuit court, dissolving the injunction, and discharging the receiver, and remanding the cause. Orders reversed and cause remandedt