Maryland case law › Cowman v. State

Cowman v. State

12 Md. 250 (1858) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: AffirmedLe Grand, C. J.✓ Good law
SummaryThe traverser was charged by indictment with an offense. He did not demur to the indictment, though he had the right to do so and could thereby have challenged whether the act charged was, in point of law, any crime at all. On appeal, he invoked matters that were proper subjects of demurrer. The Court of Appeals held that it could not relieve him because the positive language of the Act of 1852, ch. 63, § 2, prohibited quashing, staying, or reversing any judgment upon an indictment for felony or misdemeanor for any matter or cause which might have been the subject of demurrer to the indictment. Because the matters raised were matters of demurrer and no demurrer was interposed, the Court was prohibited from staying or reversing the judgment. The judgment was affirmed.
Questions presented
  • Whether the Court of Appeals can relieve the traverser on appeal for matters that could have been raised by demurrer to the indictment, where no demurrer was interposed.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Le Grand, C. J., delivered the opinion of this court. In this case there is no question before tis. The traverser did not demur to the indictment. He had the right to have done so, and if he had exercised it, he would have had an opportunity to have shown, if such was the case, that the act charged agaihst him was, in point of law, no crime whatever.

Not having demurred, we cannot relieve him, being prohibited from doing so by the positive language of the act of 1852, ch. 63. Its second section declares, “That no indictment or presentment for felony or misdemeanor shall be quashed, nor shall any judgment upon any indictment for felony or misdemeanor, or upon any presentment, Whether after Verdict, by confession, or otherwise, be stayed or reversed,’ ’ for certain specified causes, “nor for any matter or cause which might hade been a subject of demurrer to the indictment.’ ’ The matters now invoked in behalf ol' the appellant, were matters of demurrer, and as no demurrer was interposed, we cannot stay or reverse the judgment. Judgment affirmed.