Maryland case law › Creswell v. Director of Patuxent Institution

Creswell v. Director of Patuxent Institution

229 Md. 639 (1962) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: DeniedPer Curiam✓ Good law
SummaryCreswell filed an application for leave to appeal from an order recommitting him to Patuxent Institution after a jury again found him to be a defective delinquent. He raised four constitutional contentions: (1) incarceration in violation of the Fifth Amendment; (2) double jeopardy; (3) the defective delinquent law is an unconstitutional ex post facto law; and (4) cruel and unusual punishment. The Court of Appeals held these questions were not raised below and thus not preserved, citing Murray v. Director, 228 Md. 658, 661, and further noted they had been considered and rejected in prior cases, Eggleston v. State, 209 Md. 504, and Simmons v. Director, 227 Md. 661, 663. Creswell also contended that he is not a defective delinquent, that the court erred in submitting an interrogatory to the jury, and that the court improperly 'protected the image of Patuxent Institution.' The Court found th
Questions presented
  • Whether petitioner was incarcerated in violation of the Fifth Amendment to the Federal Constitution.
  • Whether petitioner was placed in double jeopardy.
  • Whether the law is unconstitutional as an ex post facto law.
  • Whether petitioner's confinement constitutes cruel and unusual punishment.
  • Whether petitioner is not a defective delinquent.
  • Whether the court erred in submitting an interrogatory to the jury.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

PER Curiam. This is an application for leave to appeal from an order recommitting the petitioner to Patuxent Institution after he was again found to be a defective delinquent. His first four contentions are that he was incarcerated in violation of the Fifth Amendment to the Federal Constitution, that he was placed in double jeopardy, that the law is unconstitutional as an ex post facto law, and that his confinement constitutes cruel and unusual punishment. It does not appear 640 that these questions were raised below.

Murray v. Director, 228 Md. 658, 661 . In any event they have been considered in prior cases and found to be without merit. Eggleston v. State, 209 Md. 504 ; Simmons v. Director, 227 Md. 661, 663. The petitioner also contends that he is not a defective delinquent, that the court erred in submitting an interrogatory to the jury, and in “protecting the image of Patuxent Institution”.

These contentions are without merit. There was sufficient testimony to warrant submission of the case to the jury. Dr. Gundry, the petitioner’s own witness, testified that the petitioner was a potential threat to society. The interrogatory in question, given to the jury in connection with the court’s careful and elaborate charge, simply contained the statutory definition with certain key words underscored.

We think there was no reversible error in the interrogatory, nor do we think there was reversible error in the court’s description of Patuxent Institution, in which the court repeated what this court has said and recited some of the legislative purposes. Other contentions, not raised below, are not subject to review here. Weddle v. Director, 227 Md. 639. Application denied.