Maryland case law › Cumberland Coal & Iron Co. v. McKaig

Cumberland Coal & Iron Co. v. McKaig

27 Md. 258 (1867) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: AffirmedBartol✓ Good law
SummaryThis appeal arose from an order of the Circuit Court for Allegany County authorizing the appellees to sell the interest of one Sherman in certain property, over the objection of the appellants, the Cumberland Coal & Iron Company. The appellants claimed an interest in the property and sought a continuance to adduce evidence in support of their claim after having failed to take testimony under the court's order of April 27, 1864. The Circuit Court refused the continuance and also rejected evidence the appellants sought to offer orally or in writing at the hearing. On appeal, the Court of Appeals (Bartol, J.) affirmed. The Court held that the question of a continuance rests in the sound discretion of the trial court and is not subject to review on appeal. It further held that because the record contained no bill of exceptions or statement of what the rejected evidence was, the appellate cou
Questions presented
  • Whether the Circuit Court erred in refusing to continue the cause on the application of the appellants, to afford them an opportunity to adduce evidence in support of their claim to the property, after they had failed to avail themselves of the opportunity afforded them to take their testimony under the Court's order of the 27th of April, 1864.
  • Whether the Circuit Court erred in refusing to allow the evidence to be given orally, or produced in writing at the hearing.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Bartol, J., delivered the opinion of this Court. The decision of this appeal has been delayed in consequence of the unfortunate illness of our brother G-oldsborough, whose co-operation in the decision lias been necessary, as the cause was heard by three Judges only, and unanimity is required. The result of our examination of the record is, that we are all of opinion there was no error in the action of the Circuit Court for which the appellants can properly claim a reversal. It is unnecessary to state at length the facts of the case, inasmuch as we concur in the views expressed by the Judge of the Circuit Court in his opinion sent up with the record. 267 (Decided 21st June, 1867.) The supposed error in his ruling consists in his refusal to continue the cause on the application of the appellants, to afford them an opportunity to adduce evidence in support of their claim to the property, after they had failed to avail themselves of the opportunity afforded them to take their testimony under tho Court’s order of the 27th of April, 1864.

The question of a continuance was one depending upon the discretion of the inferior Court, and its decision thereon is not subject to review or appeal. But the appellant complains that the Circuit Court refused to allow the evidence to be given orally, or produced in writing at the hearing. What the evidence was which was thus rejected is not stated in the record, or in any bill of exceptions, so that the appellate Court can determine upon its pertinency or materiality. Its rejection is therefore no cause for reversal.

See Clemens vs. Mayor & C. C. of Baltimore, 16 Md. Rep., 208 , and cases there cited. The appellees, under the order appealed from, will be entitled to sell only the interest of Sherman in the property in question, without concluding the rights of the appellants, if any they have to the same, leaving them free to assert that right against the purchaser, inasmuch as the question of right has not been heard and determined in this cause. Order affirmed and cause remanded.