Maryland case law › Daniel of St. Thomas Jenifer's Lessee v. Baker

Daniel of St. Thomas Jenifer's Lessee v. Baker

1 Md. 57 (1723) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Affirmed✓ Good law
SummaryThis was an ejectment action for a 100-acre tract in Saint Mary's County. The special verdict found that the land was originally taken up and surveyed for Edward Parker and William Naujfin in 1640. In 1670, Thomas Jones and Henry Mathews conveyed the land to Daniel Jenifer, father of the lessor of the plaintiff, who was his heir at law. A warrant to resurvey issued at Jenifer's request in 1671, and a certificate was returned. Critically, the jury did not find that Parker or Naujfin ever conveyed their rights to Jones and Mathews, nor that Jones and Mathews had any right to the land. The verdict further found that John Miller had quiet and peaceable possession for thirty years, then surrendered possession to William Hebb, who held for four years. Hebb, believing the lessor of the plaintiff had a right, agreed to purchase the land, paid 40 shillings current money, but then receded from the
Questions presented
  • Whether the lessor of the plaintiff had established a legal title to the land sufficient to maintain ejectment, where the special verdict failed to find that the original patentees ever conveyed their rights to the plaintiff's predecessors, or that those predecessors had any right to the land.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

EJECTMENT for a tract of land lying in Saint Mary's County, containing 100 acres. By the special verdict ■ found by the Jury, it appeared that the land in question was taken up and surveyed for Edward Parker and William Naujfm, on the 23d of October, 1640. That Thomas Jones and Henry Mathews, by deed duly executed and, bearing date the 20th of July, 1670, conveyed the land to Daniel Jenifer, father of the lessor of the plaintiff, who was his heir at law. That at the instance of Daniel Jeni fer, a warrant to resurvey the land dated the 14th of JVbvember, 1671, issued, and a certificate thereon was returned the 15th of December, 1671.

It was not found that Parker or Naujfin, or either of them, ever had made over their right to the land to Jones and Matthews, or to any other person whatsoever, or that Jones or Matthews had any right to the land. That John Miller had had the quiet and peaceable possession of the land for the space of thirty years, and that after the expiration of that space of time, the said Miller surrendered the possession of the land to one William Hebb, who continued in possession for the space of four years, and supposing the lessor of the plaintiff had a right to the land, he proposed to purchase it from him, and agreed on the price, and paid 40 shillings 58 current money towards the same. That afterwards William Hebb receded from the agreement, and purchased the land (as escheat) from the Lord Proprietary’s agent.' It was not found that John Miller had ever any right to the said land, or entered by title. The Provincial Court gave judgment upon the special Verdict, for the defendant.

Lib. P. L. No. 7. fol. 365.