Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Affirmed✓ Good law
SummaryIn this per curiam opinion, the Court of Appeals of Maryland addressed whether a case that was non-jury in the court from which it was removed remains non-jury in the court to which it is removed. The appellant, Dunn, had previously prevailed in Greenberg v. Dunn, 245 Md. 651, where the Court upheld an order of the Superior Court of Baltimore City removing an assumpsit case to the Circuit Court for Carroll County because a jury trial had not been timely prayed. After removal, Dunn prayed for a jury trial in the Circuit Court for Carroll County. Judge Weant denied that prayer and set the case for trial before the court. Dunn appealed. The Court of Appeals affirmed, relying on Chappell Chemical and Fertilizer Co. v. Sulphur Mines Co. of Va., 85 Md. 684 (unreported), reported in full at 36 A. 712, aff'd, 172 U.S. 474, and Greenberg v. Dunn, supra. The Court held that under those authorities
Questions presented
Whether a case which is non-jury in the removing court continues to be non-jury in the court to which it is removed.
Per Curiam. The appellant Dunn, who in Greenberg v. Dunn, 245 Md. 651 , persuaded us to uphold an order of the Superior Court of 540 Baltimore City removing a case in assumpsit, in which a jury trial had not been timely prayed, from that court to the Circuit Court for Carroll County (see, Houston v. Lloyd’s Consumer Acceptance Corporation, 241 Md. 10 ), is now appealing from an order of Judge Weant denying Dunn’s prayer for a jury trial and setting the case for trial before the court. The order appealed from must be affirmed, since under Chappell Chemical and Fertilizer Co. v. Sulphur Mines Co. of Va., found among the unreported cases in 85 Md. 684 , reported in full in 36 A. 712 , aff’d, 172 U. S. 474 , and Greenberg v. Dunn, supra, a case which is non-jury in the removing court continues to be non-jury in the court to which it is removed. Order affirmed, with costs.