Maryland case law › Eichelberger v. Hardesty

Eichelberger v. Hardesty

15 Md. 548 (1860) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: AffirmedLe Grand, C. J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis appeal challenged an order of the Superior Court of Baltimore City on the sole ground that the Act of 1826, chapter 192, had been repealed by the adoption of the present Maryland Constitution. The appellant argued that because the Constitution separated Baltimore City from Baltimore County and abolished the 'Baltimore county court,' there was no tribunal left to execute the Act. The Court of Appeals, speaking through Chief Judge Le Grand, rejected this contention. Without elaborating additional reasons, the Court relied on its prior decision in Gayle v. Fattle, 14 Md. 69, and on its contemporaneous decisions in the matter of the sale of the property of Robert Howard (decided at the same term, reported ante at 529), both of which recognized the continued existence of the Act of 1826. The Court therefore affirmed the order of the Superior Court, with costs, and remanded the cause for
Questions presented
  • Whether the Act of 1826, chapter 192, has been repealed by the adoption of the present Constitution of the State, it being supposed that inasmuch as that instrument separates the city from the county of Baltimore, and abolishes 'Baltimore county court,' there is no tribunal to execute it.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Le Grand, C. J., delivered the opinion of this court. The only objection urged to the order of the Superior Court, from which this appeal is taken, is, that the Act of 1826, chapter 192, has been repealed by the adoption of the present Constitution of the State, it being supposed that inasmuch as that instrument separates the city from the county of Baltimore, and abolishes “Baltimore county court,” there is no tribunal to execute it. Without assigning other reasons why this view is not tenable, we content ourselves by a refer 551 euce to the case of Gayle wife vs. Fattle, 14 Md. Rep., 69 , and the cases in the matter of the sale of the property of Robert Howard, decided at this term, (Ante, 529,) as recognizing the continued existence of the Act. We therefore affirm the order of the Superior Court.

(Decided May 16th, 1860.) Order affirmed, with costs, and cause remanded for further proceedings.