Maryland case law › England v. Montgomery Ward & Co.

England v. Montgomery Ward & Co.

249 Md. 717 (1968) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Dismissed✓ Good law
SummaryThis is a per curiam dismissal of an appeal for failure to comply with Maryland Rule 828. The appellant failed to cause to be printed, either as a separate volume or as an appendix to his brief, extracts from the record as required by Rule 828 a, which incorporates the requirements of section b (at minimum the judgment appealed from, the opinion or charge of the lower court, and the material evidence). The appellee did not exercise its option under Rule 828 c to supply the omitted material. Because the appellant failed to comply to any extent with Rule 828, the Court of Appeals dismissed the appeal under Rule 835 b (5). The Court noted that had it reached the merits, the judgment would have been affirmed. The appeal was dismissed with costs to be paid by the appellant.
Questions presented
  • Whether the appeal should be dismissed for failure to comply with Maryland Rule 828 a, which requires the appellant to cause to be printed extracts from the record including the parts provided for by section b of the Rule.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

PER Curiam. The appellant did not, as Maryland Rule 828 a requires, “cause to be printed, either as a separate volume or as an appendix to his brief, extracts from the record which shall include the parts thereof provided for by section b of this Rule * * *” (§ b requires at the least the printing of the judgment appealed from and the opinion or charge of the lower court and the material evidence). There simply was no printed extract since 718 the appellee did not choose to avail itself of the opportunity given by Rule 828 c to supply what the appellant had omitted. The appeal will be dismissed under Rule 835 b (5) because of appellant’s failure to comply to any extent with Rule 828.

Had we decided the appeal on the merits, the judgment would have been affirmed. Appeal dismissed, costs to be paid by appellant.