Maryland case law › Forwood v. State

Forwood v. State

49 Md. 538 (1878) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: DismissedBartol, C. J.✓ Good law
SummaryThe appellant, Forwood, was indicted for selling spirituous liquors to Elwood Greenfield in September 1877, with a view to profit in the prosecution of a regular trade and business, in quantities less than a pint without first obtaining a license, and also for selling spirituous liquors in quantities not less than a pint under the same circumstances. The traverser filed a special plea, to which the State demurred. The Circuit Court sustained the demurrer, and the traverser appealed. The Court of Appeals held that no final judgment had been rendered, so the appeal was taken prematurely and must be dismissed. The Court reasoned that it has been repeatedly decided that no appeal lies in a criminal proceeding in Maryland from any ruling of an inferior court upon a demurrer until after final judgment, and then the case can be brought up for review only by a proceeding in the nature of a writ
Questions presented
  • Whether an appeal lies in a criminal proceeding from a ruling of an inferior court upon a demurrer before final judgment.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Bartol, C. J., delivered the opinion of the Court. The appellant was indicted for selling to one Elwood Greenfield, in September 1877, with a view to profit in the prosecution of a regular trade and business, certain spirituous liquors in quantities less than a pint, without having first obtained a license so to do. The indictment also charges him with selling to the same person, under the same circumstances, certain spirituous liquors in quantities not less than a pint. The traverser filed a special plea, to which the State demurred.

The demurrer was sustained by the Circuit Court, whereupon the traverser took this appeal. No final judgment having been rendered in the case, the appeal was taken prematurely and must be dismissed. It has been repeatedly decided that no appeal lies in a criminal proceeding, in this State, from any ruling of an inferior Court upon a demurrer, until after final judgment; and then the case can be brought up for review only by a proceeding in the nature of a writ of error, as prescribed by Rule 1, 29th Maryland. The Act of 1872, ch. 316, allowing appeals in criminal cases, does not apply to the rulings made by the inferior Court upon a demurrer.

Kearney vs. The State, 46 Md., 422 . Appeal dismissed.