Maryland case law › Freels v. Warden of Maryland Penitentiary

Freels v. Warden of Maryland Penitentiary

230 Md. 654 (1963) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Remanded✓ Good law
SummaryBlaine H. Freels filed a petition for post conviction relief under the Maryland Post Conviction Procedure Act, raising four contentions: (i) unnecessary delay in being taken before a committing magistrate; (ii) a variance between the arrest charge of 'assault with a deadly weapon' and the indictment charge of 'assault with intent to kill'; (iii) that he was never arraigned on the indictment; and (iv) that the trial judge was prejudiced against him. The presiding judge held a hearing at which Freels was present, denied relief, and ordered him remanded to the House of Correction. However, the court failed to fully comply with Maryland Rule BK45 b, which requires that the order 'shall include or be accompanied by a short memorandum of the grounds of the petition, the questions, including specifically the federal and State rights involved, and the reasons for the action taken thereon.' Becau
Questions presented
  • Whether there was unnecessary delay in taking the petitioner before a committing magistrate.
  • Whether the petitioner was arrested for 'assault with a deadly weapon' but charged in the indictment with 'assault with intent to kill'.
  • Whether the petitioner was never arraigned on the indictment.
  • Whether the trial judge was prejudiced against the petitioner.
  • Whether the post conviction court's order complied with Maryland Rule BK45 b, which requires the order to include or be accompanied by a short memorandum of the grounds of the petition, the questions, including specifically the federal and State rights involved, and the reasons for the action taken thereon.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Per Curiam. Blaine H. Freels in his petition for post conviction relief contends: (i) that there was unnecessary delay in taking him before a committing magistrate; (ii) that he was arrested for “assault with a deadly weapon” but was charged in the indictment with “assault with intent to kill”; (iii) that he was never arraigned on the indictment; and (iv) that the trial judge was prejudiced against the petitioner. At the hearing on the petition, at which the petitioner was present, the presiding 655 judge denied the relief and ordered remand of the petitioner to the House of Correction, but the court failed to fully comply with the requirements of a post conviction procedure rule. Maryland Rule BK45 b specifies that the order of court “shall include or be accompanied by a short memorandum of the grounds of the petition, the questions, including specifically the federal and State rights involved, and the reasons for the action taken thereon.” And since the rule was not fully complied with, it is necessary to remand this case for further proceedings in accordance with subsection b of the rule.

Application for leave to appeal granted and case remanded for further proceedings consistent with this opinion.