Maryland case law › Gerende v. Board of Supervisors of Elections

Gerende v. Board of Supervisors of Elections

197 Md. 282 (1951) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: AffirmedGrason, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case came before the Maryland Court of Appeals on appeal from an order of the Board of Supervisors of Elections. The Court affirmed the order solely on the authority of Shub v. Simpson, 196 Md. 177, 76 A.2d 332 (1950), decided November 1, 1950, and filed no further opinion, referring to the Shub opinion for the reasons for its decision. The concurring opinion of Markell, J., joined by Henderson, J., explained that in Shub the Court had construed Section 11 of Article 15 of the Maryland Constitution and Chapter 86 of the Acts of 1949 together, holding that their common purpose was to prevent infiltration into state, county, or municipal government by persons engaged in attempting to overthrow the government by force or violence, and that the affidavit required by Section 15 of the statute, so construed, was a means of preventing such infiltration at its initial stage and was not an a
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

GRASON, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. The order appealed from herein will be affirmed on the authority of Shub v. Simpson, 196 Md. 177 , 76 A. 2d 332 , decided November 1, 1950. 283 Reference is made to the opinion filed in that case for the reasons of our decision in the instant case. No further opinion will be filed herein. Order affirmed with costs.

Markell, J., delivered the following concurring opinion, in which Henderson, J., joined. In Shut v. Simpson, 196 Md. 177, 192 , 76 A. 2d 332, 338 , this court said, “The purpose of Section 11 of Article 15 of the Constitution, and of Chapter 86 of the Acts of 1949, is the same and they are to be construed together to effect that purpose. That is to prevent infiltration in our state, county or municipal governments of persons who are engaged in one way or another in the attempt to overthrow the government by force or violence. We construe the affidavit required by Sec. 15 with respect to those desiring to become candidates for public office as a means of preventing such infiltration at its initial stage, thereby preventing confusion among the electors and that it is, in no sense, an additional oath of office”, and held Sec. 15 of the statute, as so construed, valid.

I dissented both as to the construction of the statute and as to its validity under Article 37 of the Declaration of Rights. As to the construction of the statute and its validity under the Maryland Constitution, that decision is final and is therefore binding on me in the instant case. As to questions raised under the Constitution of the United States, I think Sec. 15 is valid, when the required affidavit is construed as meaning only that the affiant is not a member of an organization (“subversive organization” or “foreign subversive organization”) “of persons who are engaged in one way or another in the attempt to overthrow the government by force or violence.” American Communications Association v. Douds, 339 U. S. 382 , 70 S. Ct. 674 ; United States v. Dennis, 2 Cir., 183 F. 2d 201 . Judge Henderson authorizes me to say that he concurs in this opinion.