Maryland case law › German v. Slade

German v. Slade

42 Md. 510 (1875) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: ReversedRobinson, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case arose from a suit on a promissory note brought on August 23, 1871, by the appellee against George J. German and O. German as drawers, and Joseph German (the appellant) as endorser. All defendants were returned summoned to the September Term of the Baltimore County Circuit Court, and on December 4, 1871, a judgment by default was entered against all defendants. On January 29, 1872, the judgment was extended for $737.95. On February 21, 1872, during the same term at which the judgment was rendered, the appellant filed a motion to strike out the judgment against him, alleging that he was never summoned and had no knowledge of the suit until after judgment. He filed an affidavit swearing that no summons was served upon him and that he had a good defense to the action. An affidavit of John Ditch, deputy sheriff, was also filed, stating that he received the writ of summons and served
Questions presented
  • Whether a judgment by default entered against a defendant who was never summoned and had no knowledge of the suit must be stricken out on motion filed during the term at which the judgment was rendered.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Robinson, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. Suit was brought on the 23rd of August, 1871, hy the appellee on a promissory note drawn by George J. German and O. German, and endorsed hy Joseph German the appellant. The parties were all returned summoned to the September Term of Baltimore County Circuit Court, and on the 4th of December following, a judgment hy default was entered against all the defendants, and on the 29th of January, 1872, the judgment was extended for $737.95. 512 (Decided 4th June, 1875.) On the 21st of February following, during the Term at which the judgment was rendered, the appellant filed a motion praying the Court to strike out the judgment against him, alleging among other reasons, that he was never summoned and had no knowledge that a suit had been instituted against him, until after the rendition of the judgment. At the same time he filed an affidavit in which he swears that no summons was served upon him, and that he has a good defence to the action.

An affidavit of John Ditch, depxity sheriff, was also filed, in which he says, he received the writ of summons in this case and served the same upon George J. German and O. German, but did not serve it upon Joseph German the appellant. That the writ was returned “Sd.” in pencil mark opposite each name, and that the return aSd.” opposite the name of the appellant was made through mistake. The evidence shows conclusively that the appellant was not summoned, and had no opportunity to make his defence to the cause of action. Under such circumstances the judgment against him must be stricken out.

From some inadvertence it appears that the affidavit of Ditch, the deputy sheriff, was not before the Judges of the Court below when the motion to strike out the judgment was overruled, although it appears from the docket entries that the affidavit was filed in proper time. Judgment reversed, and cause remanded.