Maryland case law › Hammett v. Dudley

Hammett v. Dudley

62 Md. 154 (1884) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: ReversedBryan, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case concerns the application of payments in a continuous running account between the plaintiffs and John Dillahay, spanning February 4, 1880, to March 30, 1882. The plaintiffs charged an accommodation draft as a debit against Dillahay. The credits on the account were more than sufficient to extinguish the draft and all antecedent debits. The legal question was whether the draft had been paid in point of law. The Court, applying the settled rule that credits must be applied to the earliest items on the debit side of a continuous account, held that the draft was paid in point of law. Consequently, the trial court properly rejected the defendant's first prayer but erred in rejecting the second prayer and in making the ruling noted in the bill of exceptions. The judgment was reversed without awarding a new trial, citing Neidig v. Whiteford, 29 Md. 178.
Questions presented
  • Whether the accommodation draft has been paid in point of law, given the continuous account and the application of credits.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Bryan, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. The question in this case relates to the application of payments. If the accommodation draft has not been paid in point of law, the judgment below was correct. There was a continuous account between the plaintiffs and John Dillahay, kept by the plaintiffs alone, and reaching from February 4th, 1880, to March 30th, 1882.

This draft is charged as one of the debits against John Dillahay. The credits are more than sufficient to extinguish this draft, and all the debits antecedent to it. Under these circum 158 stances it is settled that the credits must be applied to the settlement of the earlier items on the debit side ■ of the account. The draft was therefore in point of law paid.

The Court properly rejected the defendant’s first prayer; but erred in rejecting the second and in making the ruling mentioned in the bill of exceptions. Neidig vs. Whiteford, 29 Md., 178 . (Decided 14th May, 1884.) Judgment reversed,, without awarding a new trial.