Maryland case law › Harmon v. Director of Patuxent Institution

Harmon v. Director of Patuxent Institution

233 Md. 595 (1963) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: DeniedHenderson✓ Good law
SummaryPetitioner sought leave to appeal from an order committing him to Patuxent Institution as a defective delinquent. He alleged two grounds: (1) that he was not examined by Dr. Lerner, a court-appointed doctor, and (2) that Dr. Lerner 'got mad and turned in the report on me because I told him I wanted Dr. Michael Miller as my Doctor and no one else.' The record showed that Dr. Lerner examined petitioner at Patuxent on April 14, 1963, at the request of petitioner's court-appointed counsel, and filed a detailed four-page report finding petitioner fit the description of a defective delinquent and recommending structured therapy. Much of the report's material could only have come from petitioner. The Court noted that Code (1957), Art. 31B, sec. 7(b) entitles a person charged with being a defective delinquent, upon request, to be examined by a psychiatrist of his own choice. However, petitioner
Questions presented
  • Whether petitioner was denied his statutory right under Code (1957), Art. 31B, sec. 7(b) to be examined by a psychiatrist of his own choice, where he did not request the court or his attorney to employ Dr. Miller and did not show Dr. Miller was qualified or willing to examine him.
  • Whether petitioner's examination by Dr. Lerner was invalid because petitioner told Dr. Lerner he wanted Dr. Michael Miller as his doctor and no one else.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Henderson, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. In this application for leave to appeal from an order of commitment to Patuxent, following a finding that the petitioner 596 was a defective delinquent, the petitioner alleges that the reason for his appeal is that he was not examined by Dr. Eerner, a court-appointed Doctor. The record shows that Dr. Lerner examined the petitioner at the Patuxent Institution, at the request of his court-appointed counsel, on April 14, 1963, and filed in court a detailed four page report and impression finding that the petitioner fitted the description of a defective delinquent and recommending therapy in a structured close environment. A great deal of the material in this report could only have been obtained from the petitioner.

The petitioner also alleges that Dr. Lerner “got mad and turned in the report on me because I told him I wanted Dr. Michael Miller as my Doctor and no one else.” Code (1957), Art. 31B, sec. 7 (b) provides that a person charged with being a defective delinquent is “entitled, upon request, to be examined by a practitioner of psychiatry of his own choice * * *.” But there is no allegation that he requested the court or his attorney to employ Dr. Miller, or that Dr. Miller was qualified or willing to make the examination; on the contrary, the record shows that his attorney employed Dr. Lerner, whose qualifications are unquestioned. We find no violation of basic rights. Application denied.