Maryland case law › Harne v. State

Harne v. State

39 Md. 552 (1874) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: AffirmedGuasón, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case came before the Court of Appeals of Maryland on a writ of error. The sole error assigned was the trial court's overruling of a demurrer to the sixth count of an indictment. That count charged Allen Harne with assaulting and beating John Delosier on August 24, 1872, in Washington County. The alleged defect was the omission of the name of the party upon whom the assault was committed. The Court, speaking through Judge Guasón, held that the count sufficiently described both the offense and the party injured. The Court reasoned that the rules of criminal pleading require the nature of the offense and the party upon whom it was committed to be stated with such certainty that the accused may know what he is called upon to answer. The count charged that Allen Harne committed the assault, and then charged that he then and there beat, bruised, and wounded John Delosier. The Court noted
Questions presented
  • Whether the sixth count of the indictment is defective for omitting to state the name of the party upon whom the assault was committed.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Guasón, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. This case is before us upon a writ of error, and the only error assigned is in overruling the demurrer to the sixth count of the indictment. • That count charges “ that Allen Harne, on the twenty fourth day of August in the year of our Lord eighteen hundred and seventy two, with force and arms at the County of Washington aforesaid, in and upon one-in the peace of God and the said State, then and there being, did make an assault, and him the said John Delosier, did then and there beat, bruise, wound, &c., to the great damage of the said John Delosier and against the peace, government and dignity of the State." The defect, alleged to exist in this count, is the omission to state the name of the party upon whom the assault was committed. The rules of criminal pleading require the nature of the offence and the party upon whom it was committed, to be stated with such certainty that the accused may know what he is called upon to answer. We think that the count demurred to, sufficiently describes both the offence and the party injured.

It charges that Allen Harne committed the assault, and that he then and there beat, bruised and wounded John Delosier. It is not claimed that a battery is not sufficiently charged, but that the count does not state the party upon whom the assault was committed. It is clear that a battery cannot be committed without including an assault, and the count charges that the plaintiff in error commttted an assault, and then goes on to charge that then and there the said John Delosier was beaten, wounded, &c. We are of opinion that the count was therefore sufficiently certain to inform the accused of the 554 offence with which he was charged and the party upon whom it was committed.

The averment that the accused “on the twenty fourth day of August, 1872, committed an assault; and him, the said John Delosier, did then and there beat," &c., is a sufficiently certain averment that the accused assaulted John Delosier, as well as-that he committed the battery upon him. We are of opinion that the Circuit Court committed, no error in overruling the demurrer and its judgment will be affirmed. (Decided 20th February, 1874.) Judgment Affirmed.