Maryland case law › Harris v. State

Harris v. State

219 Md. 405 (1959) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Affirmed✓ Good law
SummaryThe appellant was convicted by a jury of common law burglary and appealed, contending that the evidence before the jury was insufficient to sustain the conviction. The Court of Appeals declined to reach the merits of the sufficiency claim because no motion for a directed verdict was made during the trial below. The Court held that, absent such a motion, it is precluded from passing on the sufficiency of the evidence. The Court further noted that there was no exception to, nor request for amplification of, the trial court's charge to the jury, so no question of law was presented under Maryland Rule 739. The Court also stated that its scrutiny of the record persuaded it that the result would not be different even if it were free to pass on the sufficiency of the evidence. The judgment was affirmed.
Questions presented
  • Whether the relevant evidence before the jury could sustain the conviction.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

PER Curiam. The appeal is from judgment and sentence that followed a verdict of guilty of common law burglary by a jury. Appellant argues that the relevant evidence before the jury could not sustain the conviction. We find nothing before this Court for review.

No motion for a directed verdict was made during the trial below and we are precluded from passing on the contention as to the sufficiency of the evidence. “In the absence of any request for an instruction there can be no review of the sufficiency of the evidence.” Auchincloss v. State, 200 Md. 310, 315 , Reynolds v. State, 219 Md. 319, No. 151, this term, just decided. There was no exception to, nor request for amplification of, the trial court’s charge to the jury, so that no question of law is presented. Maryland Rule 739. We deem it fitting to say that our scrutiny of the record persuades us that the result would not be different were we free to pass on the sufficiency of the evidence.

Judgment affirmed.