Maryland case law › Harris v. State

Harris v. State

67 Md. App. 92 (1986) · Maryland Court of Special Appeals
Maryland Court of Special AppealsDisposition: ReversedWeant✓ Good law
SummaryJohnnie Lee Harris was charged with forging a bill of exchange and uttering a false or forged bill of exchange under Md. Ann. Code art. 27, § 44. The evidence showed that Harris forged the indorsement on the back of an otherwise valid check and then cashed it. Relying on Green v. State, 32 Md. App. 567, 363 A.2d 530 (1976), the trial court granted Harris's motion for judgment of acquittal on the forgery count. However, the court refused to dismiss the uttering charge and found Harris guilty of uttering a false bill of exchange. On appeal, Harris argued that there was a fatal variance between the crime established at trial and the crime for which he was convicted. The Court of Special Appeals agreed, reasoning that because art. 27, § 44 separately lists indorsement of a bill of exchange as a subject of uttering, the holding in Green—that a person may not be convicted of forging a check wh
Questions presented
  • Whether there is a fatal variance between the crime established at trial and the crime for which appellant stands convicted when the proof shows he forged only an indorsement on a check and he was convicted of uttering a false bill of exchange.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

WEANT, Judge. Johnnie Lee Harris was charged with forging a bill of exchange and uttering a false or forged bill of exchange in violation of Md.Ann.Code art. 27, § 44. The evidence adduced in the Circuit Court for Queen Anne’s County disclosed that appellant forged the indorsement on the back of an otherwise valid check and then cashed it. Relying on Green v. State, 32 Md.App. 567 , 363 A.2d 530 (1976), the trial court granted appellant’s motion for judgment of acquittal on the forgery count.

The court refused, however, to dismiss the uttering charge and found Harris guilty of uttering a false bill of exchange. In Green , this Court held that because Md.Ann.Code art. 27, § 44 separately listed indorsement of a bill of exchange as a subject of forgery, “a person may not be convicted of forging a check when the proof shows that he forged only an indorsement.” Id. at 573, 363 A.2d at 534 . Because art. 27, § 44 also separately lists indorsement of a bill of exchange as a subject of uttering, we find that this Court’s holding in Green supports appellant’s claim that there is a fatal variance between the crime established at trial and the crime for which he stands convicted. JUDGMENT REVERSED.

COSTS TO BE PAID BY QUEEN ANNE’S COUNTY.