Maryland case law › Hay v. Jenkins

Hay v. Jenkins

28 Md. 564 (1868) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: DismissedMiller, J.✓ Good law
SummaryIn Hay v. Jenkins, the plaintiffs obtained a verdict and judgment for $510.67 on June 28, 1865. Both parties took exceptions and entered appeals, but on July 29, 1865, the plaintiffs countermanded their appeal and issued execution on the judgment. The execution was returned 'stayed by defendants' appeal; bond filed and approved by the Court, August 6th, 1865.' On January 10, 1867, the plaintiffs renewed their appeal. The defendants moved to dismiss the appeal. The Court of Appeals, speaking through Miller, J., held that while a party who withdraws an appeal may later prosecute an appeal if done within the time allowed by law, the plaintiffs' act of taking out execution after withdrawing their appeal constituted a waiver of their exceptions and barred any subsequent appeal in the same case. The Court reasoned that issuing execution on the judgment was inconsistent with prosecuting an appe
Questions presented
  • Whether a party who withdraws or countermands an appeal and then takes out execution upon the judgment waives his exceptions and cannot afterwards appeal in the same case.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Miller, J., delivered the opinion of this Court. The motion to dismiss this appeal must prevail. The verdict was in favor of the appellants, the plaintiffs below, for $510.67, and judgment for this sum and costs was rendered in their favor on the-28th of June, 1865. At the trial, both parties took exceptions and entered appeals, but subsequently on the 29th of July, the plaintiffs “countermanded” their order for an appeal, and on the same day issued an execution on the judgment which was returned “ stayed by defendants’ appeal; bond Sled and approved by the Court, August 6th, 1865.” Afterwards, on the 10th of January, 1867, they renewed their appeal.

Where an appeal is prayed and allowed and then withdrawn, the party is not precluded, if nothing 565 more is done, from afterwards prosecuting an appeal, provided he does so within the time allowed by law for appeals to be taken; but where he withdraws or countermands his appeal and then takes out execution upon the judgment, we are of opinion he thereby waives his exceptions, and cannot after-wards appeal in the same case. (Decided 21st April, 1868.) Appeal dismissed.