Maryland case law › Herbert v. Wich

Herbert v. Wich

45 Md. 474 (1877) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: ReversedStewart✓ Good law
SummaryThe plaintiff below declared for a nuisance or its continuation. The defendant pleaded in bar a former recovery for the same matter, and the plaintiff was under rule to reply. No issue to the country was tendered by the defendant, yet the docket entry of 'Issue joined' was made, and a verdict and judgment were entered for the plaintiff. The defendant moved the following day to strike out the verdict and judgment, filing reasons therefor. After a hearing date was fixed, the defendant offered to file additional reasons, which the court refused to allow. The Circuit Court overruled the motion to strike out the verdict and judgment. On appeal, the Court of Appeals (Stewart, J.) held that because the defendant had pleaded a former recovery in bar and the plaintiff was under rule to reply, and the defendant tendered no issue to the country, the docket entry of 'Issue joined' was irregular and
Questions presented
  • Whether the docket entry of 'Issue joined' was irregular and the verdict and judgment erroneous where the defendant pleaded a former recovery in bar, the plaintiff was under rule to reply, and the defendant tendered no issue to the country.
  • Whether the refusal to allow the defendant to file additional reasons in support of his motion to strike out the judgment, after the motion had been made, reasons filed, and a day fixed for hearing, is the subject of appeal.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Stewart, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. The plaintiff below declared for a nuisance or the continuation thereof. The defendant pleaded in bar, a former recovery for the same matter, and the plaintiff was under rule to reply. Under this state of the pleadings, the defendant having tendered no issue to the country, the docket entry of “Issue joined,” was irregular, and the verdict and judgment erroneous.

There being, in fact, no issue, it was a mistrial. The verdict could not cure the defect, and the motion of the defendant, made the following day, to strike out the verdict and judgment ought to have prevailed, rendering, of course, any motion in arrest of ju'dgment unnecessary. After the defendant had made the motion to strike out the judgment, and filed reasons therefor, and a day had been fixed for the hearing of the motion, the offer of the defendant to file additional reasons, was a matter within the sound discretion of the Court to permit it to be done or not, and the refusal to allow it to be done, is not the subject of appeal. 477 (Decided 11th January, 1877.) The judgment of the Circuit Court, overruling the motion of the defendant, to strike out the verdict and judgment, must he reversed. Judgment reversed, and new trial ordered.