Maryland case law › Hitch v. Fenby

Hitch v. Fenby

6 Md. 218 (1854) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: AffirmedLe Grand, C. J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis was an appeal from a decree of the Chancellor in a case involving a claim of usury. The complainant (Hitch) sought to reopen an enrolled decree, arguing that the underlying debt was affected by usury. The Court of Appeals, speaking through Chief Judge Le Grand, affirmed the Chancellor's decree. The Court held that a party who omits to make the defense of usury at law may be relieved in equity, contrary to a remark by the Chancellor, citing West v. Beanes, 3 Har. & Johns. 568. However, the Court found that the complainant's bill was filed too late: if a party has a right to open an enrolled decree because it was based on a claim affected by usury, the bill must be filed within nine months after the decree, or within nine months after being informed of the usury. The facts showed that the complainant knew of the usury before and at the date of the decree, yet waited some seven years t
Questions presented
  • Whether a party omitting to make the defense of usury at law would be relieved in equity.
  • Whether the complainant's bill to open an enrolled decree based on a claim affected by usury was filed within the time allowed by law.
  • Whether the complainant was entitled to the account he claimed.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Le Grand, C. J., delivered the opinion of this court. A very careful examination of the record in this case, has satisfied us of the justice and propriety of the chancellor’s action in the premises, and, with but one exception, we concur in all the observations and reasoning by which he sustains it. The remark to which we allude is, that a party omitting to make the defence of usury at law would not be 224 relieved in equity. The'contrary has been decided in the case of West vs. Beanes & another, 3 Har. & Johns., 568.

We refer to it to prevent misapprehension hereafter. If at any time after the decree was enrolled and the term had passed, the coihplainant had a right to open the decree' because of- its being based upon'- a claim affected by usury,we think he could only have done so within nine month's after the decree, or within the same time subsequent to his being-informed of the usury. From-the facts disclosed, it is manifest, that'before and at the date of the decree, he knew of the transactions constituting* the alleged usury, and his bill not having been filed for some seven years thereafter it i'§ too late. The cases of Berrett vs. Oliver, 7 Gill & Johns., 207, and Oliver vs. Palmer & Hamilton, 11 Gill & Johns., 146, are sufficient authority for this view.

See also Alexander's Chancery Practice, 182. In- addition to this we may remark, that there is nothing entitling the complainant to the account which- he claims. Taking the debt to be what was ascertained by the decree, (which cannot be disturbed,) the defendant has not shown credits which would probably reduce the debt below the amount now admitted by Fenby to be due. If Fenby’s account filed with his answer was rejected, the complainant on- his own proóf would owe more than the defendant now claims on the decree.

Decree affirmed*