Maryland case law › Hospelhorn v. Blankman

Hospelhorn v. Blankman

174 Md. 277 (1938) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: AffirmedPARKE✓ Good law
SummaryThis is the third of four related appeals decided by the Maryland Court of Appeals in January Term 1938, all arising from assessments against stockholders of the Maryland Trust Company. The Court expressly incorporated the reasoning of its opinion in Hospelhorn v. Poe, 198 A. 582 (No. 21 on the January Term 1938 docket), which resolved the substantive questions raised. On September 11, 1931, brokers purchased shares of Maryland Trust Company stock for the account of Meyer Blankman; the shares were issued and registered in the name of Wilmer P. Smith, an employee of the brokers, but the certificates were delivered to Blankman, who retained possession as his property. The stock remained registered in Smith's name on the company's books. Following the reasoning of No. 21, the Court held that Wilmer P. Smith, as the registered owner of the stock, is liable for payment of the assessment. Sepa
Questions presented
  • Whether Wilmer P. Smith, the registered owner of the stock, is liable for the payment of the assessment.
  • Whether the allegations of the declaration show any ground upon which there can be a joinder of Blankman.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

PARKE, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. The appeal in this case of John D. Hospelhorn, receiver of the Baltimore Trust Company, plaintiff, against Meyer Blankman and Wilmer P. Smith is the third one of four appeals on the docket of the January term, 1938. The questions raised on these appeals have been stated and the views of the court set forth in the opinion filed in the appeal of John D. Hospelhorn, receiver of the Baltimore Trust Company, against Philip L. Poe, trading as Philip L. Poe & Co., which is No. 21 on the appeal docket of this court for the January term, 1938. 198 A. 582 . On September 11th, 1931, certain shares of stock of the Maryland Trust Company were purchased by brokers for the account of Meyer Blankman, a. defendant, and the shares of stock were issued to one Wilmer P. Smith, a defendant, and an ■ employee of the brokers, and the stock registered in his name on the books of the company, but the certificates of stock were delivered by the broker to Meyer Blankman as his property and he has retained possession of the certificate, but the stock remained registered in the name of Smith.

For the reasons assigned in the opinion in No. 21, Wilmer P. Smith, the registered owner of the stock, is liable for the payment of the assessment. The allegations of the declaration do not show any ground upon which there can be a joinder of Blankman, and, for this misjoinder, the court sustained the demurrer of Blankman. The ruling is sound, and the judgment in favor of Blankman will be affirmed. Judgment affirmed, with costs to the appellee.