Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: RemandedHammond✓ Good law
SummaryIngram, an applicant for leave to appeal under Maryland's Post Conviction Procedure Act, sought to raise various points of invalidity in his conviction, mostly failure to appoint counsel with resulting prejudice. The lower court made no finding as to indigency, which Ingram had alleged and sworn to, and did not appoint counsel as the Act requires in cases of indigency. The Court of Appeals, in a per curiam opinion by Hammond, J., did not reach the merits of Ingram's claims because the lower court failed to comply with the statutory requirement to appoint counsel for indigent petitioners. The Court read the statute as requiring counsel to be appointed in every case in which the court is satisfied that the petitioner's allegation of inability to pay costs is true, unless the petitioner voluntarily and intelligently waived the right to counsel. Because the lower court made no finding on ind
Questions presented
Whether the lower court erred in failing to make a finding as to indigency and in failing to appoint counsel as required by the Post Conviction Procedure Act.
Hammond, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. This applicant for leave to appeal under the Post Conviction Procedure Act seeks to raise various points of invalidity in his conviction, mostly failure to appoint counsel, with resulting prejudice. We do not reach these points because the lower court made no finding as to indigency, which was alleged and sworn to, and did not appoint counsel as the Act requires in cases of indigency. As a result the case must be sent back. “We read the statute as requiring counsel to be appointed in every case in which the court is satisfied that the allegation of the petitioner that he is unable to pay the cost of the proceedings is true (unless petitioner voluntarily and 691 intelligently waived the right to counsel).” Byrd v. Warden, 219 Md. 681 .
See also Sutton v. Warden, 219 Md. 687 . Application for leave to appeal granted, and case remanded for further proceedings.