Maryland case law › James L. Kernan Co. v. Wilson Amusement Co.

James L. Kernan Co. v. Wilson Amusement Co.

160 Md. 17 (1930) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: ReversedBond, C. J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis is the third appeal arising from the issuance of a preliminary injunction to protect exclusive rights claimed under a contract for the production and distribution of motion picture plays. The essential facts mirror those of the immediately preceding appeal. A play titled 'All Quiet on the Western Front,' not specifically listed in the contract but constituting an additional play thereunder, was offered to the complainant on special terms with a time limit for acceptance. The complainant did not accept within that time, instead demanding the privilege of a preliminary screening of the film before deciding whether to accept or reject it. Before any exhibition occurred, the producer and distributors exercised their contractual right to withdraw and exclude that particular play as a road show. The injunction was issued upon the bill of complaint, answers, exhibits, and demurrers. The Co
Questions presented
  • Whether the bill of complaint could be maintained to support a preliminary injunction protecting exclusive rights claimed under the contract, where the complainant failed to accept the offered additional play within the time limited and the producer and distributors exercised their contractual right to withdraw and exclude the play as a road show before any exhibition.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Bond, C. J., delivered the opinion of the Court. This is a third case of appeal from the issue of a preliminary injunction to protect exclusive rights claimed under the contract stated and considered in the opinion on the first appeal, and the essential facts are the same as those in the case last considered. A play named “All Quiet on the Western Front,” one not listed but constituting an additional play under the contract, was offered to the complainant upon special terms stated, and not accepted within a time limited in the offer, the complainant demanding the privilege of a preliminary screening of the film before being required to decide to accept or reject it; and then, before any exhibition, 18 the producer and distributors exercised their right under the contract to withdraw and exclude the particular play as a road show. In this case, too, the injunction was issued upon the bill of complaint, answers and exhibits and demurrers.

This court finds the action erroneous for the reasons stated with reference to similar facts in the last preceding opinion, and conclude dhat the bill could not be maintained. Order reversed and bill of complaint dismissed, with costs to the appellants.